Issues with IslamQA.org and SeekersGuidance

First Published: 8th October 2026
Last Revised: 8th October 2026

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم الحمد لله رب العالمين الصلاة والسلام على نبيه الكريم وعلى آله وأصحابه أجمعين

In the name of Allaah, the Most Beneficent, the Most Merciful. All praise is due to Allaah, Lord of the worlds. Peace and blessings upon His noble Prophet, upon his family and all of his companions.

Introduction

As I have stated in the [About] section of this website:

One may ask, "Why create this website when there are already many other websites and resources available?" The reason is that I have found that many of the existing resources which people go to for the Hanafi Madhhab such as Islamqa.org, askimam.org, Seekersguidance.org, and others are inadequate, and have considerable issues.

Firstly, these sites do not belong to, nor do they follow the principles, foundations and methodology of Ahlus-Sunnah wa'l Jama'ah. Rather, they promote the Ahlul-Kalaam on whose misguidance the righteous generations were agreed upon, which includes the imams of this madhhab.

Secondly, a lot of their answers do not align with the Hanafi madhhab either. Sometimes, they give their own opinions and views foreign to the madhhab and tag it answered as "Hanafi Fiqh", or worse, they give weak and rejected positions, or misconstrue the words of the fuqahaa'.

I had previously mentioned that I would compile the various issues in both 'Aqeedah and Fiqh that I have found on these websites, which is the reason for my aversion to them and my discouraging the general public from relying on these sites. For now, I have chosen IslamQA.org and SeekersGuidance as my primary focus. I will, in sha Allaah, address and refute issues pertaining to both 'Aqeedah and Fiqh.

It should be noted that I have focused more extensively on SeekersGuidance. Since IslamQA.org also quotes and hosts answers from SeekersGuidance, I will address the relevant issues concerning SeekersGuidance in their respective sections and simply provide links to those refutations in the IslamQA.org section.

This article is not set in stone. If I made a mistake in answering a question, or if I add new points, I will create a log for it, In sha Allaah, which I will link here. Also, if you wish I check out a certain answer that you found problematic, are unsure about, or such, then I invite you to send it to me. Refer to my socials: Contact Me

1- IslamQA.org

According to the website's about section:

IslamQA.org is a repository of Islamic answers. We have collected over 93,950 Islamic Q&A from the official websites of various scholars and Islamic educational institutions around the world...

You can find answers to your questions from different school of thoughts (madaahib) from the Sunni scholarship...

We do not answer questions on our own...

We are not affiliated with any of the sites we have indexed.

The site does not answer any questions, rather it indexes answers from other sources, and they have mentioned that they are not scholars, but rather have contacts with some of them. More so, they say they have no affiliation with any of the sites they index.

A person may ask: if I have found problematic answers concerning ʿAqīdah and Fiqh, should not my critique instead be directed toward the websites that provided those answers? This can be answered in two ways.

First, addressing and refuting the problematic answers themselves already constitutes an indirect refutation of those websites, and there is therefore no need to engage with them directly in every instance. Second, my concern with IslamQA.org is not merely the individual answers it hosts, but the nature of the website itself. They are not people of knowledge, nor do they have qualified scholars among their ranks. They may have connections with certain scholars; however, if a scholar himself holds misguided or deviant views, he is unlikely to identify or point out the problematic aspects of an answer based upon those views.

It is precisely because IslamQA.org indexes answers without care for the truth, this is what makes it an issue in my eyes. A layman may go to this website, browse and pick certain answers, and never realize that the answer had issues. It is obvious that IslamQA.org follows the approach and ways of the Ahlul-Kalaam sects and their scholars, which is why you rarely find them taking from actual Sunni scholars. Likewise, due to their dangerous methodology, you find answers which contradict each other often, allowing a layman to think it is okay to take from any answer he wishes, essentially making it easier for laymen to follow the concessions.

• Issues in 'Aqeedah

This section deals with the issues of 'Aqeedah present in the answers of IslamQA.org, which range from mild to the most extreme, as we will see, in sha Allaah.

→ Ash'aris and Matureedis are Ahlus-Sunnah wa'l Jama'ah

Source: Ashari and Maturidi.

This is obviously the biggest indicator that the website as a whole follows the methodology and principles of the Ahlul-Kalaam sects as all of their answers on 'Aqeedah more or less repeat the beliefs of the Ahlul-Kalaam, and present it as the mainstream view. In this source, they claim:

There are two schools of theology which are generally regarded as representative of mainstream Sunni Islam: the Ash'ari and Maturidi school

This is problematic, even according to the Mutakallimeen, since most of them today claim that Islam is generally represented by the Ash'ari, Matureedi, and Athari schools. Another major issue is their claim:

Critically, with the exception of a handful, almost all scholars from our Islamic history were adherents of one of these schools. As such, both schools have a rich history of scholarship, and one is able to study theological primers of these schools to understand the basic tenets of faith.

This is one of the most repeated claims of the Mutakallimeen, however it is astounding considering there is no source or evidence ever provided to support it. Rather their 'evidence' is almost always quoting other mutakallimeen making a general blanket statement on them being the majority.

What is known among Ahlus-Sunnah is that the principle of a Muslim is that he is upon the Fitrah (natural inclination) that Allaah created all mankind upon. It is well known among the scholars of the Salaf from the Mufassireen that al-Fitrah (natural, inner disposition) meant Islam. The knowledge of Allaah Most High, according to them, is innate, self-evident, and necessary, requiring neither reflection nor inference however, reason and reflection support this innate disposition. Whereas according to the Mutakallimeen, they denied the indication of the innate disposition and restricted themselves by making the intellect the sole means of affirming the existence of the Creator. (Source)

This led to significant differences between Ahlus-Sunnah and Ahlul-Kalaam in a number of issues. Those relevant to our topic are, is it permissible to do taqleed in 'aqeedah and if someone does that, is his faith considered sound?

Addressing this, the permissibility of taqleed in matters of creed has been transmitted from the four Imams, and it is well-known among the Hanbalis, the Dhaahiris, and others. Ibn Taymiyyah attributed it to the majority of the Ummah. (Source)

The Ash'aris on the other hand, their general position was to prohibit taqleed and make rational inquiry obligatory. They prohibited taqleed in all matters of creed and made rational inquiry and reliance upon 'Ilm al-Kalaam obligatory in establishing faith in Allaah and all other beliefs. (Source)

Because of this belief, they held that the faith of one who does taqleed in matters of creed is not sound, and some of them even declared those who did so as disbelievers, whereas the Matureediyyah were more lenient than them. They held that while his faith is sound, he is disobedient for abandoning rational inquiry. (Source)

Once it is established that the Ash'aris and Matureedis obligate a person to do rational inquiry using 'Ilm al-Kalaam to establish their faith in Allaah and in His existence, then how on earth could they claim that the majority of the Ummah, as well as its scholars followed the Ash'aris and Matureedis when they did not adhere to their principles on this matter, and instead were upon the Fitrah which is Islam?! A similar 'proof' is provided where they name Ash'ari and Matureedi scholars, as their existence meant the Ummah were majority Ash'aris and Matureedis. This is flawed reasoning, and is not valid proof. I could very well name Sunni scholars, and assert the Ummah are Sunnis, this wouldn't be proof for my argument. However, Alhamdulillah, that is not our argument.

It is well known and established that the Ash'aris and Matureedis went against Ahlus-Sunnah in a number of creedal issues. That is discussed in the following works which one may refer to:

Therefore, it is incorrect and inaccurate to claim that Ash'aris and Matureedis are Ahlus-Sunnah wa'l Jama'ah, rather they are two sects from the sects of the Muslims who are misguided, and have lost their way. May Allaah guide them.

→ The Quraan in our hands today is created

Source: Is the Quran created or uncreated speech of Allaah?

This answer came from Dar al-Ifta' of Dar al-'Uloom Deoband. They claim:

So far as written and recited words of Quran are concerned, these are the created ones and they are not the attribute of Allaah, but they indicate to the Words of Allaah

I have previously written about this matter in detail. Know that this is not the belief of Ahlus-Sunnah wa'l Jama'ah, neither is it the belief of the imams of our madhhab: Abu Haneefah, Abu Yoosuf, Muhammad, Zufar, and al-Hasan, may Allaah have mercy upon them all. This innovation of dividing the speech of Allaah into His inner speech and verbal speech came after the imams. See:

More so, they quoted from al-Fiqh al-Akbar in their answer, and it is unfortunate since Imam Abu Haneefah said in that same book:

"The Quraan is the word of Allaah, whether written in the book, remembered in the hearts, recited by the tongues or revealed upon the Prophet ..."

This contradicts their opinion regarding the Quraan. And Allaah is sought for help.

→ Where is Allaah?

Source: What is the our belief concerning where is Allah?
Source: Is Allah Everywhere or is He on His Throne?

I have talked about this before in the article:

It is sufficient for now to know that Imam Abu Haneefah, the Salaf, and most of the scholars did not adhere to this belief, and various transmissions of consensus have been mentioned by the scholars on this matter. See: Ibn Abi al-'Izz al-Hanafi: Section Three: Claims

→ There is no decisive statement on Firawn being a disbeliever

Source: Did Firawn Die on Iman or Kufr?

When a brother first sent me this link, I was genuinely appalled and had no words to describe it. Then I noticed that not only does this exist, but the Dar al-Ifta which gave this answer are the scholars that IslamQA.org's admin claims to have contact with. And, I also found that IslamQA.org had another link which went against this one. This ultimately proves my point where IslamQA.org hosts contradictory answers, leaving people on confusion.

The following is the disastrous statement they said concerning the belief of Firawn:

There doesn't seem to be any decisive statement [i.e. clear and explicit] regarding his belief, rather only allusive ones [i.e. indirect or implied]

Subhan Allaah, this is transgression against Allaah, and ignorance beyond bounds. How can they say the belief of Firawn is not decisive when Allaah (may He be exalted) said about him:

كَانَ عَالِيًۭا مِّنَ ٱلْمُسْرِفِينَ ٣١
Indeed, he was a haughty one among the transgressors. [Ad-Dukhan 44:31]

And He said:

هَلْ أَتَىٰكَ حَدِيثُ مُوسَىٰٓ إِذْ نَادَىٰهُ رَبُّهُۥ بِٱلْوَادِ ٱلْمُقَدَّسِ طُوًى ٱذْهَبْ إِلَىٰ فِرْعَوْنَ إِنَّهُۥ طَغَىٰ فَقُلْ هَل لَّكَ إِلَىٰٓ أَن تَزَكَّىٰ وَأَهْدِيَكَ إِلَىٰ رَبِّكَ فَتَخْشَىٰ فَأَرَىٰهُ ٱلْـَٔايَةَ ٱلْكُبْرَىٰ فَكَذَّبَ وَعَصَىٰ ثُمَّ أَدْبَرَ يَسْعَىٰ فَحَشَرَ فَنَادَىٰ فَقَالَ أَنَا۠ رَبُّكُمُ ٱلْأَعْلَىٰ فَأَخَذَهُ ٱللَّهُ نَكَالَ ٱلْـَٔاخِرَةِ وَٱلْأُولَىٰٓ
15. Has there come to you the story of Mûsâ (Moses)? 16. When his Lord called him in the sacred valley of Tûwâ, 17. Go to Fir'aun (Pharaoh); verily he has transgressed all bounds (in crimes, sins, polytheism, disbelief). 18. And say to him: "Would you purify yourself (from the sin of disbelief by becoming a believer)?" 19. "And that I guide you to your Lord, so you should fear Him?" 20. Then [Mûsâ (Moses)] showed him the great sign (miracles). 21. But [Fir'aun (Pharaoh)] belied and disobeyed. 22. Then he turned his back, striving (against Allâh). 23. Then he gathered (his people) and cried aloud,24. Saying: "I am your lord, most high." 25. So Allâh, seized him with punishment for his last and first transgression. [An-Nazi'at 79:15-25]

Moosa (peace be upon him) made the du'a':

وَقَالَ مُوسَىٰ رَبَّنَآ إِنَّكَ ءَاتَيْتَ فِرْعَوْنَ وَمَلَأَهُۥ زِينَةًۭ وَأَمْوَٰلًۭا فِى ٱلْحَيَوٰةِ ٱلدُّنْيَا رَبَّنَا لِيُضِلُّوا۟ عَن سَبِيلِكَ ۖ رَبَّنَا ٱطْمِسْ عَلَىٰٓ أَمْوَٰلِهِمْ وَٱشْدُدْ عَلَىٰ قُلُوبِهِمْ فَلَا يُؤْمِنُوا۟ حَتَّىٰ يَرَوُا۟ ٱلْعَذَابَ ٱلْأَلِيمَ
And Mûsâ (Moses) said: "Our Lord! You have indeed bestowed on Fir'aun (Pharaoh) and his chiefs splendour and wealth in the life of this world, our Lord! that they may lead men astray from Your Path. Our Lord! Destroy their wealth, and harden their hearts, so that they will not believe until they see the painful torment." [Yoonus 10:88]

And what was Allaah's response to this?

قَالَ قَدْ أُجِيبَت دَّعْوَتُكُمَا
[Allāh] said, "Your supplication has been answered." [Yoonus 10:89]

These are explicit and clear statements in the Quraan which clearly indicate that Firawn was a disbeliever, and that he was punished for his disbelief. Likewise, so does the Sunnah of the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him). The scholars have also consistently mentioned consensus on the disbelief of Firawn. This includes another article also hosted by IslamQA.org which justifies my initial criticism of their inability to know right from wrong. (Source) (IslamQA.org Source)

Someone may object to us, arguing that the answerer later said:

However, by looking into the Qur'anic verses as well as the Hadith, we can conclude that the overwhelming amount of evidence indicates towards his disbelief

We would answer that they misunderstood what the criticism is about. We are not saying that the answerer believes that Firawn was a believer. Rather, the issue and criticism is their claim that there is no "decisive statement" on his belief.

According to the English language, "decisive statement" in this context would mean that there is no clear, explicit statement that directly establishes what Firawn's belief was, that there are only statements that suggest, hint at, or indirectly point toward what his belief may have been. This is entirely false, with no valid basis.

→ Confirming hands for Allaah is wrong

Source: Is Confirming Hands for Allah Kufr?

Answered in: Confirming hands for Allah is wrong

→ Ibn 'Arabi is respected and admired

Source: What is the status of Ibn 'Arabi in Sunni Islam?

Answered in: Ibn 'Arabi is respected and admired

• Fiqh

These are the issues I have compiled from IslamQA.org related to Fiqh (jurisprudence). These issues are riddled with mistakes, inconsistencies, and at times opposition to the madhhab.

→ Innovated practice in advice

Source: Innovated Practice in Advice

The sister in the article asks for advice concerning her marriage, which is troubled. She asks for a du'a' that she may read which may alleviate her pain. Now, the principle regarding Du'a's is that you may make du'a' using any word you wish to use, and in anything you wish to ask. However, when it comes to legislated actions and du'a's, then there must be textual evidence backing the practice in question. The "advice" given in the article is:

Recite ya Lateef ya Wadood (یا لطیف یا ودود) after Isha Salah taking 11 grains of black pepper and recite 11 time durood before and after the dua and have a thought of making the husband kind and affectionate. Having recited, blow on the black peppers, burn them in fire and pray Allaah

First of all, there is no evidence provided for such a practice. Secondly, how could this be tagged as "answered by Hanafi Fiqh"?! Granted that Dar al-'Uloom Deoband are Hanafis, this does not mean that their answer was according to the madhhab of Imam Abu Haneefah (may Allaah have mercy on him). Rather, this answer seems to stem from the Sufi influences present in them. To say "do this X thing, and you get Y" without textual evidence is considered an innovation. Instead, they should have limited themselves to offering the sister realistic and practical advice, along with du'a's as mentioned in the Sunnah.

→ Building upon graves is okay

Source: How can you say that building on graves is permitted?

This was answered in the section on SeekersGuidance as the answerer is Faraz Rabbani. Refer to: Lamenting the destruction of shrines

2- SeekersGuidance

According to the website's about section:

SeekersGuidance is a platform that aims to provide authentic Islamic knowledge and guidance to seekers of knowledge. We strive to present information in a clear and accessible manner, while ensuring its accuracy and reliability.

However it is more fitting to call them SeekersMisguidance. Their issues extend beyond matters of 'Aqeedah and Fiqh, which is why I have another category specifically for those issues titled, "Controversies".

Some background on its founder, he is Faraz Rabbani. They gave his biography as:

Shaykh Faraz Rabbani spent ten years studying with some of the leading scholars of recent times, first in Damascus, and then in Amman, Jordan. His teachers include the foremost theologian of recent times in Damascus, the late Shaykh Adib al-Kallas (may Allah have mercy on him), as well as his student Shaykh Hassan al-Hindi, one of the leading Hanafi fuqaha of the present age. He returned to Canada in 2007, where he founded SeekersGuidance in order to meet the urgent need to spread Islamic knowledge–both online and on the ground–in a reliable, relevant, inspiring, and accessible manner.

However, it is less well known that before SeekersGuidance, he was on another website called SunniPath.qa. Some of the issues we will present also come from that website.

Throughout this entire section, one should note that often, the answerer is not Faraz Rabbani himself, but someone else. However all these answers ultimately come back to Faraz Rabbani as under almost every answer, it is written "Checked and Approved by Faraz Rabbani". Therefore, any answer given, whether still available or removed, all of them were either checked directly by him, or worse he never actually checks these answers. This is something I will discuss in the controversies section.

• Aqeedah

This section deals with the issues of 'Aqeedah present in the answers of Seekers(Mis)Guidance

→ Confirming hands for Allaah is wrong

Source: Is Confirming Hands for Allah Kufr?

Faraz Rabbani says regarding affirming the hands of Allaah as per its apparent meaning:

As for wrongful opinions: don't busy yourself with them.

He parrots the rhetoric of the Ahlul-Kalaam, straying from the path and way of Ahlus-Sunnah wa'l Jama'ah who affirmed the attributes of Allaah as they were mentioned in the Quraan and Sunnah, per its apparent meaning, without interpreting them, asking the 'how', negating them, or comparing them to the creation. What Faraz Rabbani says is not but the views of the Matureediyyah, not the imams of our madhhab. I have discussed the Matureedi approach, and that of our imams in the following article: Are Hanafis and Matureedis the Same? Belief in the Attributes of Allaah

Moreover, I have discussed the approach of Ahlus-Sunnah - in general - to the attributes of Allaah and presented evidences for it from the Quraan, the Sunnah, and the early generations. Refer to: Reality of Allaah's Attributes

→ Calling upon 'Ali ibn Abi Taalib is pure affirmation of Tawheed.

Source: Calling on Other than Allah?

This was answered by Faraz Rabbani on his old website which was sunnipath.com. He has taken down the site and most articles from it likewise are also gone. However, the Wayback Machine has archived several posts, one of which is this.

The question asked is very simple. The questioner asks:

I see on some internet forums, people writing such things as "Ya Ali I invoke thee" - I wanted to know is it allowed to say such things? Does this not smack of shirk?

What does this Rabbani say? He says:

This is pure affirmation of Divine Oneness. How can it ‘smack of shirk.’

Exalted is Allaah, this is a statement of explicit and clear disbelief and shirk! I have addressed a similar topic in this section, see: Disastrous answer in Istighathah and Tawassul

This evil and vile man who makes clear and explicit shirk "pure affirmation of divine oneness" clearly did not "study" under Hanafi fuqaha'. Did he not refer himself to what the imams of our madhhab said?! By Allaah, At-Tahaawi (may Allaah have mercy on him) is clear when he said:

Allaah, the Most High, responds to supplications and fulfills needs, and He controls all things and nothing has any control over Him. None can be independent of Allaah for as much as the blink of an eye. Whoever considers himself independent of Allaah for as much as the blink of an eye has committed disbelief and has become among the people of Hell.

Many of the scholars of the Hanafi madhhab have explained this creed, and they have important remarks in the explanation of the mentioned statement of Imam at-Tahaawi, which is originally the position of the three imams absolutely. It would take too long to present the words of every single one of these commentators on this decisive quote. Therefore, I would like to mention the overall sum of the words of these scholars, such as al-Babarti, al-Maydani, an-Naasiri, Ibn Abi al-'Izz and some others.

They said: Allaah commanded His servants to supplicate to Him and promised them an answer, encouraging the servants to pray to Him alone without any partner. For Allaah is Modest and Generous, and feels shy to leave His servant's hands empty when raised to Him.

Thus, Allaah has emphasized and commanded His servants to pray to Him alone during afflictions. Many texts have been revealed in the Book and the Sunnah confirming this requirement and making it obligatory upon the servants to call upon the Lord of servants during distress, not any created being.

This is because Allaah alone owns everything, so nothing is impossible for Him and nothing is difficult for Him to grant. Furthermore, He is Modest, Generous, Merciful, Bountiful, Bestower, Giver, and Answerer, capable of fulfilling all needs. He is described with perfect mercy and absolute power over all things, experiencing no difficulty in fulfilling the needs of those in distress. Neither Muslim nor disbeliever can dispense with Allaah even for a blink of an eye; even the polytheists are in need of Allaah for when harm touched them at sea, they called upon none but Allaah alone, associating no partners with Him.

These disbelievers understood this important point, they believed that no one can dispense with Allaah in times of distress. For that reason, since everything other than Allaah is in need of Him, and He alone is the Self-Sufficient, who urged people to supplicate to Him and desired that they ask Him alone for their needs without partner.

Allaah delights in the supplication of His servant and their asking of Him, as well as the display of humility before Him. Whoever does not ask Allaah in times of hardship and does not pray to Him during afflictions incurs His anger and wrath, unlike the son of Adam, as it is said: "Allaah becomes angry if you leave asking Him, while the son of Adam, when asked, becomes angry." So whoever sees himself as self-sufficient without Allaah even for a blink of an eye, turning away from Him and seeking help from other than Him, has disbelieved and will abide eternally in the Fire. What ruin could be greater than this?

This is because whoever does not call upon Allaah does not truly know Him, even if he claims to know Him, for if he truly acknowledged Him, he would not contradict his acknowledgment by abandoning supplication and requests to Him during hardships and resorting instead to creation.

Imam al-Alusi, the commentator and Mufti of the Hanafis in Baghdad (d. 1270 AH) in [روح المعاني], followed by his son Nu'maan al-Alusi (d. 1317 AH) in [جلاء العينين في محاكمة الأحمدين], with the wording belonging to the first, said regarding this issue:

Seeking help from a created being and making them a means to request supplication: there is no doubt in its permissibility if the person asked is alive...As for when the request is made to someone who is dead or absent, no scholar doubts that it is impermissible and that it is an innovation not practiced by any of the Salaf... Nor has it been reported from any of the Companions, may Allaah be pleased with them, who were the most eager of all creation for every good, that they ever asked anything from a dead person...

May Allaah account this evil man for his statement, and may He protect us from the likes of Rabbani.

→ Lamenting the destruction of shrines

Source: The Loss of Meaning: The Destruction of Muslim Holy Sites
Source: How can you say that building on graves is permitted?

In the first article, Faraz Rabbani laments the destruction of shrines that are built upon the graves of pious, righteous people, or saints. He questions those who "see no problem with this", describing they "may even feel that this is a good thing because an “exaggerated emphasis” is placed on the holiness of such sites. This overstated emphasis, they fear, could weaken or cloud sound understanding of the Oneness of God and reliance solely upon Him." Then starts to call that into question, saying it is "alarming" for one to say this, or to view it as something good.

He tries to argue that these sites are blessed, he says:

However, Muslims from the earliest generations have sought blessings (tabarruk) of individuals, objects, places and times.

He then proceeds to give examples of this.

The first example is that of the Companions (may Allaah be pleased with them), and how they sought blessings from things such as the Prophet (peace be upon him)'s hair, sweat, leftover water from his wudu, and other similar things. The scholars have unanimously agreed on the permissibility of seeking blessings through the relics of the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him. (Source)

Faraz Rabbani then claims:

We see this practice in subsequent generations, too.

This is not correct. The truth is that it has not been transmitted from the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him) that he ever commanded seeking blessings through anyone other than him among the Companions or others, whether through their physical persons or through their relics, nor did he direct to anything of that sort. Likewise, it has not been reported that this type of seeking blessings occurred on the part of the Companions (may Allaah be pleased with them) with anyone other than him (peace and blessings upon him) neither during his lifetime (peace and blessings upon him) nor after his death, peace and blessings be upon him.

Imam ash-Shaatibi al-Maaliki (may Allaah have mercy on him) addressed this matter explicitly in [الاعتصام] where he said:

The Companions (may Allaah be pleased with them), after his death (peace and blessings be upon him), none of them did anything of that nature with respect to those he left behind. For the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him) left no one in the nation after him better than Abu Bakr as-Siddeeq (may Allaah be pleased with him) - he was his successor, yet no one did anything of that nature with him. Nor did they do so with 'Umar (may Allaah be pleased with him), who was the best of the nation after him, nor likewise with 'Uthman, then 'Ali, then the rest of the Companions, than whom no one in the nation was better.
None of them has been proven through any authentic chain to have sought blessings through any of those means or similar ways. Rather, they restricted themselves in regarding them to following their example in actions, statements, and lifestyles in which they followed the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him). Therefore, this constitutes a consensus (Ijmaa') among them on leaving those things.

Al-Haafidh Ibn Rajab al-Hanbali (may Allaah have mercy on him) stated in [الحكم الجديرة بالإذاعة]:

Likewise, seeking blessings through relics was only practiced by the Companions, may Allaah be pleased with them, with the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him. They did not practice it with one another, nor did the Successors practice it with the Companions, despite their high status. This indicates that it is only to be practiced with the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, such as seeking blessings through his ablution water, his bodily remnants, his hair, and drinking what remained of his drink and food. In general, these matters are a trial for both the one who venerates and the one who is venerated, because of the fear that excessive veneration may lead to innovation, and perhaps even progress to a form of shirk. All of this arose from imitating the People of the Book and the polytheists, which this Ummah was prohibited from doing.

So once it is known that this was not the practice of the Salaf from these two great scholars, we will answer the narrations presented by Faraz Rabbani in support of his misguidance.

The first is that of Imam ash-Shaafi'i doing tabarruk with the shirt of imam Ahmad (may Allaah have mercy on them both). Faraz Rabbani cites it from [تاريخ دمشق] of al-Haafidh Ibn Asakir, who narrated it through two chains.

To talk briefly about the content, the report contains that Imam ash-Shaafi'i sent a letter from Egypt through Ar-Rabee' ibn Sulaymaan to Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal, informing him of a dream in which the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him) conveyed greetings of peace and foretold that Ahmad would face trial regarding the creation of the Quraan but would be raised with honor for his steadfastness. Upon reading it, Imam Ahmad wept and gifted Ar-Rabee' his inner shirt as a reward for the good news. When Ash-Shaafi'i learned of this, he asked Ar-Rabee' to soak the shirt in water so he could share in its blessings. It is then reported that Ash-Shaafi'i used that water daily to wipe his face, seeking blessings through it.

Once the content is understood, the aforementioned chains are:

Ibn 'Asakir: Abu al-Mudhaffar 'Abd al-Mun'im ibn 'Abd al-Kareem al-Qushayri informed me, Abu Bakr Ahmad ibn al-Husayn al-Bayhaqi informed me, Abu 'Abd ar-Rahman Muhammad ibn al-Husayn ibn Muhammad ibn Moosa, while it was being read to him, informed us, saying: I heard Muhammad ibn 'Abdullah ibn Shadhan say: I heard Abu al-Qaasim ibn Sadaqah say: I heard 'Ali ibn 'Abd al-'Azeez at-Talhi say: Ar-Rabee' said to me...

Ibn Asakir: 'Abd al-Jabbar ibn Muhammad ibn Ahmad al-Hawari told us, Abu Sa'eed 'Abd al-Wahid ibn 'Abd al-Kareem al-Qushayri informed us, al-Haakim Abu Ja'far Muhammad ibn Muhammad as-Saffaar informed us, 'Abdullah ibn Yoosuf informed us, I heard Muhammad ibn 'Abdullah ar-Razi say: I heard Ja'far ibn Muhammad al-Maaliki say: Ar-Rabee' ibn Sulayman...

The first chain contains Abu 'Abd ar-Rahmaan as-Sulami. Muhammad ibn Yoosuf al-Qattan said,

Abu 'Abd ar-Rahmaan as-Sulami was untrustworthy, and he used to fabricate hadeeths for the Sufis.

Adh-Dhahabi said:

He was not strong in hadeeth.

And he said:

In general, his writings contain fabricated hadeeths and stories. In his 'Haqa'iq at-Tafseer', there are also things that are completely unacceptable. Some of the scholars considered them to be from the heretical apostasy of the Baatiniyyah, while others considered them to be spiritual knowledge and reality. We seek refuge in Allaah from misguidance and from speaking according to one's desires, for all goodness lies in following the Sunnah and holding firmly to the guidance of the Companions and the Successors, may Allaah be pleased with them.

Another defect in its chain is that there is an unknown person in the chain above as-Sulami.

As for the second chain, then there is also another unknown person in its chain.

Ibn Muflih al-Hanbali (may Allaah have mercy on him) said in [الآداب الشرعية]:

Shaykh Taqi ad-Deen [Ibn Taymiyyah] said, "They fabricated stories about Imam Ahmad concerning the Sunnah and piety." He then mentioned this story, as well as the story of his refusal to eat bread that had been baked in the house of his son Saalih when he was appointed as a judge.

Adh-Dhahabi in [سير أعلام النبلاء] stated about Ar-Rabee' ibn Sulaymaan:

He was not a traveler. As for what is narrated that Ash-Shaafi'i sent him to Baghdad with his letter to Ahmad ibn Hanbal, it is not authentic.

Thus, this incident is not authentic, and one cannot rely on it as evidence that Tabarruk by other than the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him) is permissible. (Source)

The second incident mentioned by Faraz Rabbani is that of Imam ash-Shaafi'i praying at the grave of Imam Abu Haneefah (may Allaah have mercy on them both). It is reported Ash-Shaafi'i said:

Indeed, I seek blessings through Abu Haneefah, and I visit his grave every day. Whenever I have a need, I pray two rak'ahs and then go to his grave and ask Allaah for my need. It is not long before my need is fulfilled.

Al-Khateeb reported it in [تاريخ بغداد] with the chain:

Al-Qaadi Abu 'Abdullah al-Husayn ibn 'Ali ibn Muhammad as-Saymari informed us, saying, Umar ibn Ibraheem al-Muqri informed us, saying, Makram ibn Ahmad narrated to us, saying, 'Umar ibn Ishaaq ibn Ibraheem narrated to us, saying, 'Ali ibn Maymoon narrated to us, saying, I heard ash-Shaafi'i say, ...

There are multiple defects, both in chain and the text.

The first defect is in the chain, as 'Umar ibn Ishaaq ibn Ibraheem is unknown. The second is that if 'Ali ibn Maymoon is not 'Ali ibn Maymoon ar-Raqqi, then he is unknown as well. The text is also defective, as the scholars rejected its content, especially since Imam ash-Shaafi'i himself disliked the action being reported.

The last example mentioned by Faraz Rabbani is a supposed narration of imam Ahmad (may Allaah have mercy upon him) wanting to be buried in the Qatee'ah cemetery because it was authentic near him that a prophet was buried there. He cited from [طبقات الحنابلة] of Ibn Abi Ya'la. Al-Khateeb narrated in [تاريخ بغداد] through Abu Ya'la ibn al-Faraa'.

One may see that Faraz Rabbani does not pay attention to what he cites as he says this story is about imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal. However, Ibn Abi Ya'la has clearly mentioned this about the entry of 'Abdullah ibn Ahmad ibn Hanbal, and likewise al-Khateeb has also mentioned this is about 'Abdullah ibn Ahmad ibn Hanbal (may Allaah have mercy on them both). This raises the question whether Faraz Rabbani even knew the source he quoted, that if he merely copied it from some place else without ever verifying its contents. Or the alternative which is Rabbani does not know how to read the sources he quotes, this seems to be a recurring pattern as we will point out when relevant.

As for the chain of narration, then while Ibn Abi Ya'la does not mention it, al-Khateeb reports with the chain:

Abu Ya'la Muhammad ibn al-Husayn ibn Muhammad ibn al-Faraa' al-Hanbali narrated to me saying, Abu Taahir ibn Abi Bakr narrated to me saying, My father related to me from a man who used to frequent Abu Bakr ibn Maalik that he was asked, "Where would you like to be buried when you die?" He replied, "In al-Qatee'ah, for 'Abdullah ibn Ahmad ibn Hanbal is buried in al-Qatee'ah." He was asked about this, meaning 'Abdullah and he said, "I think he had instructed that he be buried there." He then said, "It has been established to me that a prophet is buried in al-Qatee'ah, and for me to be in the vicinity of a prophet is more beloved to me than for me to be in the vicinity of my own father."

The obvious defect being here that Abu Bakr is relating from an unknown person from Abu Bakr ibn Maalik. Even if we assume the narration is authentic, it does not provide any kind of evidence for the view that shrines over graves is permissible. Perhaps Faraz Rabbani mentions this to try and argue that there are blessings in certain places. While that is true, to know whether a certain place is blessed or not is linked to textual evidences, not to individual opinions.

With that, we now talk about the main topic of the article which is lamenting the destruction of shrines, domes and the likes over graves. Faraz Rabbani claims to have learned and studied under "leading Hanafi fuqaha'", yet it makes the mind wonder why Faraz Rabbani is saddened for the destruction of domes, shrines, and such over the graves, when the Hanafi madhhab prohibitively dislikes any kind of building built over graves, and the various narrations support destroying such buildings.

To clarify, prohibitively disliked [مكروه تحريمي] is the same as prohibited [حرام] in ruling, except that the latter applies when the evidence is definitive [قطعي], and the former when speculative [ظنّي]. There is another difference though that is not relevant here.

Imam Muhammad ibn al-Hasan ash-Shaybaani in [الآثار] narrates:

Abu Haneefah informed us, from Hammad, from Ibraheem, who said: "It used to be said, 'Raise the grave so that it can be recognized as a grave and therefore not be stepped on.'"

Imam Muhammad comments on it, saying

This is what we follow, and We do not see that anything should be added to what has already been taken out [i.e. the soil that is dug up for the grave is what should be used to fill it up again, more soil should not be added into it]. We dislike that it be plastered, coated with clay, or that a mosque, marker, or inscription be placed beside it or upon it. We dislike that bricks be used to build with or placed inside the grave. We do not see any harm in sprinkling water over it, and this is the opinion of Abu Haneefah, may Allaah have mercy on him.

Al-Qudoori in [المختصر] said:

The grave should be raised in a mound and not be flattened.

Shaykh Al-Hindi commented on it in [مختصر القدوري مع المعتصر الضروري ص ١٧٩]:

His statement: "should be raised in a mound", is due to al-Bukhaari's narration from Sufyaan that he saw his grave (the Prophet's, peace be upon him) in a mound.

What it means for the grave to be raised in a mound, means it should be curved, like the hump of a camel.

'Ala ad-Deen as-Samarqandi in [تحفة الفقهاء] stated:

The Sunnah regarding the grave is that it should be raised in a mound, not made square, plastered with mud, or plastered. Abu Haneefah considered it disliked to build over the grave and to mark it with a sign, and Abu Yoosuf said, "I consider it disliked to write on it," due to what has been narrated from the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, that he prohibited making graves square, plastering them, and writing on them...and it is disliked to add more soil to the soil of the grave that has been removed from it, because that is considered like building a structure.

So let the reader reflect that if merely adding more soil to the grave is considered like building a structure, then what about building a dome, or a shrine, or a mosque over it?

Abu Bakr al-Kasani in [بدائع الصنائع في ترتيب الشرائع] said:

It is disliked to plaster the grave with gypsum and to plaster it with clay. Abu Haneefah considered it disliked to build over the grave and to mark it with a sign. Abu Yoosuf considered writing on it disliked. Al-Karkhi mentioned this based on what was narrated from Jaabir ibn Abdullah (may Allaah be pleased with them both) from the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, that he said: "Do not plaster graves, do not build over them, do not sit on them, and do not write on them." This is because such things fall under decoration, while the deceased has no need for it. It is also a waste of wealth without any benefit, and therefore it is considered disliked.

Az-Zayla'i said in [تبيين الحقائق شرح كنز الدقائق]

It is disliked to build over a grave, to sit on it, to sleep on it, to walk over it, to relieve oneself upon it by urinating or defecating, to mark it with a sign by means of writing or something similar, to pray toward it, or to pray among the graves, due to the hadeeth of Jaabir that the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, forbade plastering the grave, sitting on it, building over it, writing on it, and walking over it.

As mentioned by our scholars, when dislike is used as an absolute term, it refers to prohibitive dislike. Specifically regarding this issue of building over the graves, Ibn 'Aabideen clarified what is meant by dislike here is prohibitive. He said in [رد المحتار]:

And its apparent meaning is that the dislike is prohibitive.

Note that the citations above are about the matter of building over graves in principle, I found Faraz Rabbani in another article [i.e. second source] claiming that there is an established position for building upon graves not being an issue, citing from At-Tumurtaashi and Al-Haskafi. He says:

As such, it is not a matter where condemnation is allowed, as the position that building on grave is permissible is an established position both within the Hanafi school and in other schools of Sunni law.

Once again, Faraz Rabbani fails to read what he cites. He claims Ibn 'Aabideen in his Hashiyah supports the position, however he clearly did not read that Ibn 'Aabideen said:

وَأَمَّا الْبِنَاءُ عَلَيْهِ فَلَمْ أَرَ مَنْ اخْتَارَ جَوَازَهُ.
As for building on it (i.e. the grave), then I have not seen anyone permit it.

Subhan Allaah, then consider that he claims to say:

At the same time, the way of my teachers is to act on the stronger position–not building, but allowing reinforcement on the sides...

Yet in the first article, he appears to condemn destruction of buildings over graves, which the people who hold the "stronger position" hold. He even considers this "alarming" as came before. The hypocrisy of this man is blatant.

And what do we do say about graves that already have buildings over them, such as the domes and shrines that Rabbani laments over? Then we shall cite from Shihaab ad-Deen Mahmood al-Alusi in his [روح المعاني]. He is one of the scholars, closer to our time, and he knew what the people had started doing at graves. Regarding Allaah's saying:

وَكَذَٰلِكَ أَعْثَرْنَا عَلَيْهِمْ لِيَعْلَمُوٓا۟ أَنَّ وَعْدَ ٱللَّهِ حَقٌّ وَأَنَّ ٱلسَّاعَةَ لَا رَيْبَ فِيهَآ إِذْ يَتَنَـٰزَعُونَ بَيْنَهُمْ أَمْرَهُمْ ۖ فَقَالُوا۟ ٱبْنُوا۟ عَلَيْهِم بُنْيَـٰنًا ۖ رَّبُّهُمْ أَعْلَمُ بِهِمْ ۚ قَالَ ٱلَّذِينَ غَلَبُوا۟ عَلَىٰٓ أَمْرِهِمْ لَنَتَّخِذَنَّ عَلَيْهِم مَّسْجِدًا ٢١
And thus We made their case known (to the people), that they might know that the Promise of Allâh is true, and that there can be no doubt about the Hour. (Remember) when they (the people of the city) disputed among themselves about their case, they said: "Construct a building over them; their Lord knows best about them;" (then) those who won their point said (most probably the disbelievers): "We verily shall build a place of worship over them." [Al-Kahf 18:21]

Al-Alusi stated:

This verse has been used as evidence for the permissibility of building over the graves of righteous people, taking a mosque over them, and praying there. Among those who mentioned this was ash-Shihab al-Khafaji in his marginal notes on al-Baydawi. This is a false, invalid, corrupt, and worthless opinion.

And he said later on:

If the grave itself is built upon without any of the previously mentioned necessities, such as by making a surrounding enclosure or a dome over it in a public burial ground, such as land that had previously been unused but where people regularly bury their dead, or land endowed for this purpose, then demolishing it is even more deserving of being obligatory because of the violation involved, as stated in al-Majmoo'. This is because of the restriction it causes, while the structure remains permanently after the body has decayed, preventing people from using that area.

He also mentioned:

A group of scholars gave the fatwa that everything built in the Qarafah cemetery of Egypt should be demolished, even the dome of Imam ash-Shaafi'i, may Allaah have mercy on him, which was built by some of the kings. Everyone should demolish such structures unless doing so is feared to cause some harm or greater corruption, in which case the matter should be referred to the leader, based on the words of Ibn ar-Rif'ah concerning reconciliation.

Ibn Nujaym in [البحر الرائق شرح كنز الدقائق] said:

As for what has been reported in the Saheeh [i.e. Saheeh Muslim] from 'Ali: "Do not leave any raised grave without leveling it", this is understood as referring to whatever exceeds the mound-like raising of the grave.

Ibn al-Hummam in [فتح القدير] also stated something similar, saying:

As for what is found in Muslim from Abu al-Hayyaj al-Asadi, who said: 'Ali said to me: "I am sending you on the same mission upon which the Messenger of Allaah, peace and blessings be upon him, sent me: that you do not leave any statue without erasing it, nor any raised grave without leveling it." This is understood as referring to what people used to do by raising graves through elaborate and tall construction. What we mean, however, is not that degree of elevation, but rather only the amount of soil that rises above the ground and is distinct from it.

Therefore the reality of the matter is laid bare. The hypocrisy, ignorance and misguidance of Faraz Rabbani is apparent. He only gives subjective answers and distorts the texts to support his innovations and misguidance, may Allaah protect us from his evil.

→ Delaying the declaration of faith

Source: Delaying the Declaration of Faith

The answerer, 'Abdur-Raheem says,

This is not a matter of any legal consequence. The person who turns up to say the shahada (declaration of the statements of faith) is already a Believer. Iman is affirmation and submission to the truth (tasdiq) and this happens in one’s heart. This is sufficient to be saved on the Day of Judgement. [Laqqani, Jawharat al-Tawhid]

Furthermore, he says,

The shahada is to inform the Muslim community that one is a believer, so the rulings of a Muslim are applied to one, such as the washing upon death and burial amongst the Muslims.

I have already discussed the belief of Ahlul-Kalaam regarding faith in the following article: Are Hanafis and Matureedis the Same? Understanding of Eeman (Faith)

This answer is disastrous as it takes away the blessing of Islam from those who wish to join His religion. To recite the Shahaadah to convert is mandatory and part of Islam as is well known. It is not reported from any one of the Companions, their Successors, their successors, and those after them who followed them in righteousness, that they considered belief in the heart to be enough. This is because there are many hadeeths indicating the obligation of pronouncing the two testimonies of faith. Among that is what was reported from Mu'adh ibn Jabal (may Allaah be pleased with him) that the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him) said to him when sending him to Yemen:

"You will come to a people from the People of the Book. When you come to them, call them to testify that there is no god but Allaah and that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allaah..."

Narrated by Al-Bukhaari (1496), Muslim (19), and An-Nasaa'i (2435). In the version of Muslim:

So call them to bear witness that there is no god but Allaah and that I am the Messenger of Allaah...

This hadeeth indicates that the call to non-Muslims towards Islam begins by calling them to affirm the oneness of Allaah Most High and the messengership of His Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings upon him) because this is the first condition for the acceptance of deeds and the validity of all prescribed acts of worship. It is also through this that a person enters Islam. Without it, he remains upon disbelief and is not addressed with the other laws of Islam.

Imam an-Nawawi said in his commentary of Saheeh Muslim [شرح النووي على مسلم]:

The people of the Sunnah among the hadeeth scholars, jurists, and theologians [i.e. some Ahl al-Kalaam] agreed that the believer who is judged to be among the people of the qiblah and who will not remain eternally in the Fire can only be someone who firmly believes in his heart in the religion of Islam, with a conviction free of doubts, and who, in addition, has uttered the two testimonies of faith. If he limits himself to only one of them, then he is not considered among the people of the qiblah at all. Rather, he will remain eternally in the Fire, unless he is unable to utter them due to a defect in his tongue, because death overtakes him before he is able to do so, or for some other reason. In that case, he is a believer.

In [الموسوعة الفقهية الكويتية]

The jurists have mentioned that there are three ways by which a person is judged to be a Muslim: explicit declaration, following another's status, and indication. As for the explicit declaration, it is for a person to openly pronounce the two testimonies of faith. As for following another's status, it means that the dependent person takes the ruling of the person upon whom they depend with regard to Islam. For example, a young child of a disbeliever follows his father if his father accepts Islam... As for the method of indication, it means taking the practical route of entering Islam through an action.

Therefore, for 'Abdur-Raheem to say the Shahadah has no legal consequence is incorrect, as it is one of the ways one enters Islam, and as mentioned, necessary to enter Islam with.

In [الموسوعة الفقهية الكويتية], it says:

All the Imams of the Salaf agreed that the first thing a servant is commanded to do is to say the two testimonies. All the messengers' messages called to the monotheism contained in this statement, and to affirm Allaah's divinity and lordship, Glorified and Exalted is He. It is stated in the Noble Quraan:
{And We did not send any messenger before you except that We revealed to him: 'There is no deity except Me, so worship Me.'}
Thus, this statement was the first thing by which a person entered Islam. And when it is the last thing with which a Muslim leaves this world, he enters Paradise, as the Prophet ﷺ said:
'Whoever's last words are "There is no deity except Allaah" will enter Paradise.'
Believing in the messengership of Muhammad ﷺ also means believing in everything he brought from Allaah and everything contained in his message. It also means believing in all the messengers and affirming the truth of their messages.

The answer says "Checked and Approved by Faraz Rabbani" who claims to have studied with Hanafi jurists, then I wonder how he missed this in [فتح القدير] of Ibn al-Hummam:

In Sharh at-Tahaawi: Abu Yoosuf was asked about how a man becomes Muslim. He said, he says, 'I testify that there is no deity except Allaah, and that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allaah,' affirms what has come from Allaah, and renounces the religion that he had adopted. It also indicates that the Christian says, 'I testify that there is no deity except Allaah and that Muhammad is His servant and Messenger,' and renounces Christianity. The same applies to Judaism and other religions.

Consider that Imam Abu Yoosuf was asked how one becomes a Muslim, his answer that one must say the shahaadah and affirm it in his heart is against what they said that you do not need to say the shahadaah. More so, the implication from this is if that a person does not fulfill either one of the conditions, then he is not a Muslim as either he did not affirm in his heart what he was reciting (i.e. the shahaadah), or he did not verbalize with his tongue what he had affirmed in his heart.

And Allaah knows best.

→ Interpreting the image of Allaah

Source: What Does The Narration “Allah created Adam In His/his Image” Mean?

Relevant: Reality of Allaah's Attributes

Once again Seekersguidance repeats their Ahlul-Kalaam approach to the attributes of Allaah, which the righteous generations and scholars of Ahlus-Sunnah warned from. The specific words in this answer are disasterous, to say the least. He says about the verses and narrations that came regarding the names and attributes of Allaah:

Interpreting the outwardly problematic part of the text...

This word choice is poor, as the answerer seems unaware as to what he has just alluded to. The words he used give the impression that the various verses and narrations of the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him) are problematic and must be interpreted through a "suitable and methodologically sound manner". It implies that the issue and problematic thing is in the very essence of the text, and must be changed to avoid it being "problematic".

We seek refuge in Allaah, does this mean that Allaah, the Exalted and Almighty, and His Messenger (peace be upon him) use "problematic words" which require correction from "suitable and methodological way" which has not been reported from either the Prophet (peace be upon him), his companions, or their successors, and those after them?! We say to them as 'Abdullah ibn Mas'ood said (may Allaah be pleased with them) said to a group of innovators, "Have you become more knowledgeable than the Companions of Muhammad (peace be upon him)?!"

As for the answer itself, while the answerer mentioned the hadeeth, "Allaah created Adam in His image". He conveniently leaves out other narrations which are more explicit and more direct that the "image" being referred to here is the image of Allaah, which is an attribute of His.It was narrated by Al-Bukhaari (6573) and Muslim (182) from Abu Hurayrah (may Allaah be pleased with him):

Some people said to the Messenger of Allaah, peace and blessings be upon him, "O Messenger of Allaah, will we see our Lord on the Day of Resurrection?" He, peace and blessings be upon him, said: "Will you have any difficulty seeing the moon on the night of the full moon?" They said, "No, O Messenger of Allaah." ... The hadeeth continues: "Allaah will gather the people on the Day of Resurrection and say, 'Whoever used to worship something, let him follow it.' So those who used to worship the sun will follow the sun, those who used to worship the moon will follow the moon, and those who used to worship the false gods will follow the false gods. This nation will remain, including its hypocrites. Then Allaah, Blessed and Exalted is He, will come to them in a form other than the one they know [فَيَأْتِيهِمُ اللَّهُ فِي غَيْرِ الصُّورَةِ الَّتِي يَعْرِفُونَ]. He will say, 'I am your Lord.' They will say, 'We seek refuge in Allaah from you. This is our place; our Lord will come to us. When our Lord comes to us, we will recognize Him.' Then Allaah, Most High, will come to them in the form that they know [فَيَأْتِيهِمُ اللَّهُ فِي الصُّورَةِ الَّتِي يَعْرِفُونَ]. He will say, 'I am your Lord.' They will say, 'You are our Lord.' Then they will follow Him..."

It is narrated by At-Tirmidhi (3235) from Mu'adh ibn Jabal (may Allaah be pleased with him) who said, the Messenger of Allaah (peace be upon him) said:

"Indeed, I will tell you what kept me from you this morning. I got up during the night, performed ablution, and prayed as much as was decreed for me. I became drowsy during my prayer until I felt very heavy, and then I saw my Lord, Blessed and Exalted is He, in the most beautiful form [أحسَنِ صُورةٍ]."

Imam at-Tirmidhi said about this hadeeth, "This hadeeth is Hasan Saheeh". And he said:

I asked Muhammad ibn Isma'eel [al-Bukhaari] about this hadeeth, and he said, 'This hadeeth is Hasan Saheeh.'

From these hadeeths, it is known that the image is affirmed for Allaah, Most High, in a manner befitting Him, Glorified and Exalted is He. His form is one of His attributes and does not resemble the attributes of created beings, just as His Essence does not resemble the essences of created beings.

Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah said in [بيان تلبيس الجهمية في تأسيس بدعهم الكلامية]:

"The word 'form' in the hadeeth is like the other names and attributes that have been transmitted, which may be used for created beings in a restricted sense. When they are used absolutely for Allaah, they are specific to Him, such as the All-Knowing, the All-Powerful, the Merciful, the All-Hearing, and the All-Seeing; and such as His creating with His two Hands, His rising over the Throne, and similar things."

In the Arabic language, surah (form) means shape, appearance, reality, and attribute. Thus, everything that exists must have a form. Shaykh al-Islam said as in [بيان تلبيس الجهمية في تأسيس بدعهم الكلامية]:

"Just as every existing thing must have attributes pertaining to it, everything that exists independently must have a form in which it exists. It is impossible for there to be something existing independently that has no form in which it exists."

He also said as in [بيان تلبيس الجهمية في تأسيس بدعهم الكلامية]:

"There was no disagreement among the Salaf of the first three generations that the pronoun in the hadeeth refers back to Allaah, Most High. This is reported through numerous chains from a number of the Companions, and the context of all the hadeeths indicates this... However, when the Jahmiyyah became widespread in the third century, a group held that the pronoun referred to something other than Allaah. This was even attributed to a number of scholars who were known for knowledge and adherence to the Sunnah in most of their affairs, such as Abu Thawr, Ibn Khuzaymah, Abu ash-Shaykh al-Asbahani, and others. For this reason, the leading scholars of the religion and other scholars of the Sunnah criticized them."

Ibn Qutaybah in [تأويل مختلف الحديث] stated:

What I believe, and Allaah, Most High, knows best, is that the soorah [image] is no more surprising than the two Hands, the fingers, and the eye. The familiarity with those came about because they are mentioned in the Quraan, while the uneasiness regarding this one came about because it is not mentioned in the Quraan. We believe in all of them, and we do not say about any of them, with a how or limit.

For a more in-depth explanation of this issue, refer to:

→ Disastrous answer in Istighathah and Tawassul

Source: What Is the Ruling of Seeking Assistance (Istighatha) through Other than the Prophet (Allah Bless Him and Give Him Peace)?

This answer is the most dishonest, misleading, and dangerous among all the answers here. The questioner asks,

Is it permissible to do Istighatha/Isti‘ana/Istimdad (beseeching for help) through any being (angels and deceased humans included) other than the Prophet Muhammad (Allah bless him and give him peace)? For example, saying “Madat Ya Jilani or Himmat Ya Jilani” (Save (me/us) Ya Jilani or Help Ya Jilani).

The answerer, Irshaad answers it by saying:

Tawassul through the awliya and righteous believers is permitted according to the Four Schools of Sunni Islam, for the same reason that tawassul through the Prophet (Allah bless him & give him peace) is permitted. [al-Mawsu‘a al-Fiqhhiyya al-Kuwatiyya]

This implies that the answer to the questioner is yes, that he may beseech for help from angels, dead humans, the Prophet (peace be upon him) and others, and that Tawassul is the same as Istighathah. He then cited [الموسوعة الفقهية الكويتية] trying to argue that what the questioner asked is permitted by all four madhhaib. However this dishonest misguider has not quoted the full context of the work, or even the work in its relevant place. From [الموسوعة الفقهية الكويتية] and onwards:

Tawassul in technical usage does not depart from its linguistic meaning [i.e. to draw near]. Thus, it is used for that through which one draws closer to Allaah, the Most High, such as performing acts of obedience and abandoning prohibited things. This is how the exegetes understood the statement of Allaah, the Most High:
And seek the means of nearness to Him. [Al-Maidah 5:35]
Tawassul is also used to mean drawing closer to Allaah by requesting another person to make supplication, and it is also used for supplication through which one seeks nearness to Allaah, the Most High, by means of one of His Names, one of His Attributes, or through one of His creation, such as a prophet, a righteous person, the Throne, and other such things.

After defining Tawassul, they discuss words related to Tawassul, the first of which is al-Istighathah. They say:

Istighathah means seeking relief and assistance, and this is also its technical meaning. Istighathah is different from tawassul, because istighathah only occurs in a situation of hardship, whereas tawassul may occur both in a situation of hardship and in a situation of ease. Ibn Taymiyyah said:
No one has said that seeking tawassul through a prophet is the same as seeking istighāthah through him. Rather, ordinary people who use various things as means of tawassul in their supplications, such as one of them saying, "I seek nearness to You through the right of Shaykh so-and-so or through his sacred status," or "I seek nearness to You through the Tablet and the Pen," or through the Ka'bah, or other things that they mention in their supplications, know that they are not seeking istighathah through these things. For the one who seeks istighathah through the Prophet ﷺ is asking him and seeking from him. The one through whom tawassul is sought is not called upon, nor is anything requested or asked of him. Rather, something is sought through him. Everyone distinguishes between the one who is called upon and the one through whom something is sought.

This deceiver goes against the very text he cited, ignoring that they distinguished between Tawassul and al-Istighathah where Tawassul is something sought for, not called upon. The questioner is asking about calling upon others, not what this deceiver thinks. As for his claim that Tawassul by the righteous was permitted by all four madhhabs, then under the heading of Tawassul through the righteous, the book says:

The ruling on seeking tawassul through righteous people other than the Prophet ﷺ does not differ from the aforementioned disagreement regarding seeking tawassul through him.

First, we establish the fact they did not claim it is permissible by consensus of the four madhhaib, as falsely claimed by the deceiver. Rather, they mention it was differed upon. Second, the three kinds of Tawassul from the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him) which they mentioned had no difference of opinion were:

A- Seeking tawassul through the Prophet (peace be upon him) by requesting his supplication during his lifetime.

B- Seeking tawassul through the Prophet (peace be upon him) on the Day of Judgment by asking people to ask him to intercede for them with their Lord at the place of gathering. This will certainly occur, contrary to the view of the Mu'tazilah.

C- Seeking tawassul through the Prophet (peace be upon him) in the sense of having faith in him and loving him. This is like saying, "I ask You by Your Prophet Muhammad," while intending: "I ask You through my faith in him and my love for him," or, "I seek nearness to You through my faith in him and my love for him," and similar expressions.

As for differed upon type, they said:

Seeking tawassul through the Prophet (peace be upon him) after his death:

The scholars differed regarding the permissibility of seeking tawassul through the Prophet (peace be upon him) after his death, such as a person saying: "O Allaah, I ask You through Your Prophet," or "through the status of Your Prophet," or "through the right of Your Prophet."

Thus, this type of Tawassul is the only one differed upon, through the Prophet (peace be upon him). This means that they likewise differed on whether you can do Tawassul by the righteous, they did not claim it is permitted unconditionally, as the deceiver claims.

Why did this deceiver not quote from the section of al-Istighathah, rather than Tawassul? That was more relevant here, but since that deceiver did not do so, it falls upon us. From [الموسوعة الفقهية الكويتية], discussing about al-Istighathah, they said:

Istighathah linguistically: Seeking relief and assistance. Istighathah according to the Sharee'ah: Its meaning does not depart from the linguistic definition, as it consists of seeking help and the alleviation of distress.

Then discussing the ruling of al-Istighathah, they said that there are four kinds, the fourth kind is:

Fourth: Prohibited. This is when one seeks help from someone who has no power or influence over spiritual matters, whether the one from whom help is sought is a human being, a jinn, an angel, or a prophet, during his lifetime or after his death:
And do not invoke besides Allaah that which can neither benefit you nor harm you. [Yoonus 10:106]

This is the type of al-Istighathah the questioner is asking about, yet this deceiver says this is permitted by all the four madhhaib and it is the "truth"! They said regarding the fourth kind of al-Istighathah with the creation:

To ask the one from whom help is sought for something that he is incapable of doing, and not to ask Allaah, Blessed and Exalted, such as seeking his help to remove distress from him or to bring him provision. This is not permissible, and the scholars have regarded it as shirk.

Regarding al-Istighathah from the angels, they said:

Seeking help from them is seeking help from other than Allaah, the Exalted, and every form of seeking help from other than Allaah is prohibited, based on the statement of the Messenger of Allaah, peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him: "Help is not sought from me. Rather, help is sought from Allaah." And also based on his statement, peace be upon him, regarding when Ibraheem was thrown into the fire: Jibreel met him and said to him, "Do you have a need?" He replied, "As from you, then no."

Therefore, one can see the disaster this answer brings, Irshaad deceives the questioner by misquoting from [الموسوعة الفقهية الكويتية], claiming that it is permissible to seek help from others than Allaah, while the source itself refutes him and exposes his ignorance. This article is manifest, not in truth, but in blatant shirk being permitted by this deceiver, may Allaah protect us from his likes.

As for this topic - in general - then many works have been written on it, and much has been debated. As a Muslim, it is obligatory upon us to worship Allaah, the Most High, as He commanded, and how the Prophet (peace be upon him) taught us. The way of the Companions of Muhammad, peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him, was that they worshipped Allaah alone according to what their Prophet had commanded them. They worshipped none but Allaah, and they did not call upon anyone besides Allaah, whether from those in the heavens or those on the earth, neither angels, stars, prophets, nor their statues. Rather, they knew that all of this was among the shirk that Allaah and His Messenger had forbidden. They did not call upon any created being, neither an angel, jinn, nor human being, whether a prophet or anyone else. Neither at his grave nor in his absence. They sought help only from Allaah, sought victory only from Allaah, and relied only upon Allaah. They did not call upon an absent or dead person, seek his help in times of distress, complain to him, or ask him for forgiveness, guidance, or victory. Rather, they asked Allaah for all of this. Likewise were the Successors (Tabi'een) and their successors (Atba' at-Tabi'een).

The Prophet (peace be upon him) said,

Adhere to my Sunnah and to the Sunnah of the al-Khulafa ar-Raashideen (the rightly guided caliphs), those who guide to the right way. Cling to it stubbornly [literally: with your molar teeth]. Beware of newly invented matters [in the religion], for verily every bidah (innovation) is misguidance.

Narrated by At-Tirmidhi and Abu Dawood. At-Tirmidhi said, "This hadeeth is Hasan Saheeh." Mentioned by an-Nawawi in [Riyadh as-Saaliheen (157)]

And he said, peace and blessings upon him,

"I order you (to stick to) my Companions, then those who come after them, then those who come after them.."

Narrated by At-Tirmidhi (2165) who said, "This hadeeth is Hasan Saheeh Ghareeb from this route."

So follow these righteous generations instead of deceivers like Irshaad and Rabbani, we seek refuge in Allaah from their evil.

→ Ibn 'Arabi is respected and admired

Source: What Is the Status of Ibn 'Arabi in Sunni Islam?

Before we cite what the article itself contains, we will briefly mention who Ibn 'Arabi is, what he held, and why SeekersGuidance opinion of him I've included as refuting a matter in 'Aqeedah.

Ibn 'Arabi, he is Muhammad ibn 'Ali ibn Muhammad ibn Ahmad at-Ta'i al-Haatimi al-Andalusi al-Mursi, Abu Bakr. Nicknamed as 'Muhyi ad-Deen' (the Reviver of the Religion) though far from it, known as Ibn al-'Arabi the Sufi. He traveled through many lands until he settled in Damascus, Syria, where he died. He was the leader of the Sufis in his time, and he was among those who called toward hulool (incarnationism) and ittihaad (monism/unionism). He reconciled "contradictions", opened the gates of disbelief, and there is no power nor strength except through Allaah. He was intelligent, yet he was not pious. He authored many works, the most famous of which are: al-Futuhaat al-Makkiyyah, Fusoos al-Hikam, At-Tajalliyaat al-Ilahiyyah Fi Soorah al-Insaniyyah, al-Ahadiyyah, al-Ittihaad, and many others that numbered in the hundreds! This evil man perished in Rabee' ath-Thani in the year 638 AH.

A relevant side note that scholars drop the definite article when referring to "Ibn 'Arabi" in order to distinguish him from the Maaliki jurist Ibn al-'Arabi, author of Ahkaam al-Quraan. This practice is prevalent among scholars of the east, later scholars, and contemporaries, which is the more accurate usage. If they define him with the definite article ("al-"), they add "the Sufi," "author of Al-Fusoos," "Muhyi ad-Deen at-Ta'i," or "al-Haatimi," using whatever distinguishes him from the jurist.

Some beliefs of Ibn 'Arabi are:

1- Unity of Existence (Wahdat al-Wujood): He believed that Allaah is the sole true existence and that the creation is identical to the Creator in reality, considering the Creator to be the essence of all created things.

2- Pre-eternity of the World (Qidam al-'Alam): He held the view that the world is co-eternal with Allaah and coexists with Him, rather than being created after non-existence.

3- Attributing Blameworthy Qualities to Allaah: He viewed Allaah as described by all names and attributes in existence, including creation-based flaws, blameworthy traits, and imperfect descriptions.

4- Divine Manifestation in Women: He believed that Allaah's ultimate and most complete manifestation occurs in women, viewing love for women as a form of divine love.

5- Validity of Idolatry and All Faiths: He asserted that worshiping idols or other beings than Allaah is ultimately worshiping Allaah Himself, viewing all religions and beliefs as valid because every deity worshipped is a manifestation of the Divine.

6- Divinity and Faith of Firawn: He claimed that Firawn possessed divinity and that his declaration of faith at the moment of drowning was genuine and accepted.

7- Superiority of Sainthood over Prophethood: He held distinct views on prophecy and sainthood (wilayah), viewing sainthood as a higher or more enduring spiritual station than prophethood.

8- Cessation of Hellfire's Punishment: He believed in the eventual end of torment for the disbelievers in Hell, holding that their punishment would eventually turn into a form of pleasure.

Unfortunately some scholars defended Ibn 'Arabi, arguing that we can interpret his speech which opposes the Sharee'ah, and that he might have intended a meaning that is contrary to his apparent words. However, the explanations of Ibn 'Arabi's students and followers were clear in meaning that Ibn 'Arabi's words were upon their apparent nature, and there was no hidden meaning behind them. These commentators whose works were relied upon were Mu'ayyid ad-Deen al-Jandi (d. 700 AH), the student of as-Sadr al-Qunawi (the main student and stepson of Ibn 'Arabi), 'Abd ar-Razzaq al-Qashaani (d. 730 AH), the student of al-Jandi, Dawood al-Qaysari (d. 751 AH) who was a student of al-Qashani, 'Abd ar-Raheem al-Jami al-Hanafi, and 'Abd al-Ghani an-Nablusi (d. 1143 AH).

Al-Jandi studied from the main student of Ibn 'Arabi and his stepson as-Sadr al-Qunawi, and Al-Qashani took from him, and Al-Qaysari took from him, so these are the highest experts of Ibn 'Arabi's school of thought. As for Al-Jami and An-Nabulsi, then they are well known Sufis and their commentaries of al-Fusoos are held in high esteem among them.

Thus, it makes sense for me to include this issue in the section of 'Aqeedah, this article has to do with this heretical apostate (i.e. Ibn 'Arabi), what he held, and what opinion Faraz Rabbani holds of him.

So what does he say about this heretical apostate? He says

The predominant view across mainstream scholars has been to respect (even admire) Ibn 'Arabi as a scholar and master of the science of Islamic spirituality. At the same time, they affirm that his writings shouldn't–or can't–be read by those who aren't trained to understand his usage and terminology.

It is alarming that he says that the "mainstream scholars" respect or even admire Ibn 'Arabi. How far from truth this. Either Faraz Rabbani knew this is not the case but claimed so anyways, or he may lack the fear of Allaah, as he did not research about the matter before making such blatantly false statements.

There are nearly two hundred scholars of this Ummah from the 6th century all the way to the 14th century who criticized and condemned ibn 'Arabi, declared him a transgresser and innovator, and many even declared him a disbeliever!

From the sixth century AH: Ibn al-Jawzi al-Hanbali (d. 597 H).

From the seventh century AH: Ibn Nuqtah al-Hanbali (d. 629 H), al-Haafidh ibn as-Salaah ash-Shaafi'i (d. 643 H), Isma'eel al-Kurani (d. 644 H), Ibn al-Haajib al-Maaliki (d. 646 H), Abu Muhammad al-Mahdawi (d. 649 H), Abu al-Mudhaffar al-Kaamili (d. 652 H), Al-'Izz ibn 'Abd as-Salaam ash-Shaafi'i (d. 660 H), al-Haafidh ibn Musdi (d. 663 H), Najm ad-Deen al-Hakeem as-Sufi (d. 678 H), Ibn Shaddaad al-Ansari al-Halabi (d. 684 H), Rasheed ad-Deen Sa'eed al-Hanafi (d. 684 H), Qutb ad-Deen Ibn al-Qastalani ash-Shaafi'i (d. 686 H), Ibraheem al-Ja'bari ash-Shaafi'i (d. 687 H), al-Qaadhi Shams ad-Deen al-Asbahani ash-Shaafi'i (d. 688 H), Ibn Bint al-A'az ash-Shaafi'i (d. 695 H), and al-Qaadhi ibn Wasil al-Hamawi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 697 H).

From the eighth century AH: al-Haafidh ibn Daqeeq al-'Eed ash-Shaafi'i (d. 702 H), Ibraheem ar-Raqqi al-Hanbali (d. 703 H), Ibn Nooh al-Qoosi (d. 708 H), Sa'd ad-Deen al-Harthi al-Hanbali (d. 711 H), Shams ad-Deen al-Jazari ash-Shaafi'i (d. 711 H), Ibn Shaykh al-Hizamiyeen al-Hanbali (d. 711 H), Al-Qaadhi Shaqeer ash-Shaafi'i (d. 715 H), Najm ad-Deen at-Tufi al-Hanbali (d. 716 H), Abu al-'Ala as-Sukooni al-Maaliki (d. 717 H), 'Abd ar-Rahman al-Ja'bari as-Sufi (d. 723 H), Noor ad-Deen al-Bakri ash-Shaafi'i (d. 724 H), Al-Yuneeni al-Hanbali (d. 726 H), Shaykh al-Islam Ahmad ibn Taymiyyah (d. 728 H), al-Qaadhi Najm ad-Deen al-Balisi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 729 H), Al-'Ala al-Qunawi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 729 H), Kamaal ad-Deen al-Maraghi (d. 729 H), Baha' ad-Deen al-Janadi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 730 H), al-Qaadhi Badr ad-Deen ibn Jama'ah ash-Shaafi'i (d. 733 H), Ibn Sayyid an-Naas ash-Shaafi'i (d. 734 H), 'Ala ad-Dawlah as-Samnani (d. 736 H), Sayf ad-Deen as-Su'udi (d. 736 H), Ibn al-Kattani ash-Shaafi'i (d. 738 H), Ibn al-Barizi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 738 H), Burhaan ad-Deen as-Safaqoosi al-Maaliki (d. 742 H), al-Haafidh al-Mizzi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 742 H), al-Qaadhi Sharf ad-Deen az-Zawawi al-Maaliki (d. 743 H), al-Haafidh ibn 'Abd al-Haadi al-Hanbali (d. 744 H), Shams ad-Deen As-Safaqoosi al-Maaliki (d. 744 H), Abu Hayyan al-Andalusi (d. 745 H), Kamaal ad-Deen al-Udfuwi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 748 H), al-Haafidh Adh-Dhahabi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 748 H), Ibn al-Wardi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 749 H), Al-Manufi al-Maaliki (d. 749 H), al-Haafidh ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyyah (d. 751 H), Taqi ad-Deen as-Subki ash-Shaafi'i (d. 756 H), 'Aadh ad-Deen al-Eeji ash-Shaafi'i (d. 756 H), Ameer al-Itqaani al-Hanafi (d. 756 H), Ibn Hishaam al-Hanbali (d. 761 H), Ibn Naqash ash-Shaafi'i (d. 763 H), Salah ad-Deen as-Safadi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 764 H), Al-Yafa'i ash-Shaafi'i (d. 768 H), Baha' ad-Deen as-Subki (d. 773 H), Siraaj ad-Deen al-Hindi al-Ghaznawi al-Hanafi (d. 773 H), al-Haafidh Ibn Katheer ash-Shaafi'i (d. 774 H), Shams ad-Deen al-Mawsili ash-Shaafi'i (d. 774 H), Lisaan ad-Deen Ibn al-Khateeb (d. 776 H), Ibn Abi Hajalah al-Hanafi (d. 776 H), al-Qaadhi Ibn al-Kafri al-Hanafi (d. 776 H), Ibn Marzooq al-Maaliki (d. 781 H), Shihaab ad-Deen al-Adhra'i ash-Shaafi'i (d. 783 H), Shams ad-Deen ibn Muhhib as-Samit al-Hanbali (d. 789 H), Al-Qaadhi al-Akhna'i al-Maaliki (d. 789 H), 'Ala ad-Deen as-Siraami al-Hanafi (d. 790 H), Jamaal ad-Deen ad-Duwali ash-Shaafi'i (d. 790 H), Sa'd ad-Deen At-Taftazani al-Hanafi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 791 H), Al-Qaadhi ibn Abi al-'Izz al-Hanafi (d. 792 H), Zayn ad-Deen al-Kattani ash-Shaafi'i (d. 792 H), Jalaal ad-Deen at-Tabbani al-Hanafi (d. 793 H), and al-Qaadhi Ibn Bint al-Maleeq ash-Shaafi'i (d. 797 H).

From the ninth century AH: Ibn 'Arafah al-Maaliki (d. 803 H), Ibn Ayyub ad-Dimashqi (d. 803 H), al-Haafidh Siraaj ad-Deen ibn Mulaqqin ash-Shaafi'i (d. 804 H), Siraaj ad-Deen al-Bulqeeni ash-Shaafi'i (d. 805 H), al-Haafidh Al-'Iraqi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 806 H), Ahmad ibn Ibraheem az-Zabeedi (d. 806 H), 'Eesa ibn Hajjaaj as-Sa'di (d. 807 H), al-Haafidh al-Haythami ash-Shaafi'i (d. 807 H), Ibn Khaldoon al-Maaliki (d. 808 H), Shams ad-Deen al-'Ayzari ash-Shaafi'i (d. 808 H), Ibn al-Khayaat ash-Shaafi'i (d. 811 H), 'Ali ibn al-Hasan al-Khazraji az-Zabeedi (d. 812 H), Noor ad-Deen al-Adamiy ash-Shaafi'i (d. 813 H), Shihaab ad-Deen Ahmad an-Nashiri ash-Shaafi'i (d. 815 H), Al-Ba'ooni ash-Shaafi'i (d. 816 H), Jamaal ad-Deen al-'Awadi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 816 H), Az-Zayn al-Maraghi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 816 H), Majd ad-Deen al-Fayroozabaadi (d. 817 H), Muhammad ibn 'Umar ibn Shaw'an al-Hanafi (d. 817 H), Zayn ad-Deen an-Nahriri al-Maaliki (d. 818 H), Ahmad ibn 'Abd as-Samad ash-Shu'ubi, Taghri Barmash al-Qaahiri al-Hanafi (d. 823 H), Ibn Noor ad-Deen al-Muzi'i ash-Shaafi'i (d. 825 H), Abu Zur'ah ibn al-'Iraqi (d. 826 H), Ibn Damamini al-Maaliki (d. 827 H), al-Qaadhi ad-Dafari al-Maaliki (d. 828 H), Ibn al-Qaadhi 'Ijloon ash-Shaafi'i (d. 828 H), Muhammad ibn Ibraheem adh-Dhahiri (d. 830 H), Taqi ad-Deen al-Fasi al-Maaliki (d. 832 H), Qaasim ibn 'Umar ad-Damati al-Yamani (d. 832 H), Shaykh al-Muqriyyeen Ibn al-Jazari ash-Shaafi'i (d. 833 H), Nidhaam ad-Deen as-Siraami al-Hanafi (d. 833 H), Zayn ad-Deen al-Ansari ash-Shaafi'i (d. 833 H), Sadr ad-Deen Ibn al-'Ajami al-Hanafi (d. 833 H), Ibraheem al-Itkawi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 834 H), al-Qaadhi Shams ad-Deen ibn al-Fanari al-Hanafi (d. 834 H), Hasan ibn Muhammad ash-Shaafi'i (d. 834 H), Abu al-'Abbas ash-Shaafi'i (d. 834 H), al-Qaadhi At-Tafahaani al-Hanafi (d. 835 H), Shihaab ad-Deen al-Harazi (d. 836 H), Ibn al-Muqri ash-Shaafi'i (d. 837 H), Ibn Zaknoon al-Hanbali (d. 837 H), al-Qaadhi ibn al-Amanah ash-Shaafi'i (d. 839 H), Ahmad ash-Shifaki ash-Shirazi (d. 839 H), Jamaal ad-Deen ibn al-Khayaat ash-Shaafi'i (d. 839 H), Ibn al-Wazeer al-Yamani (d. 840 H), Al-'Ala' al-Bukhaari al-Hanafi (d. 841 H), Ibn Taqi al-Maaliki (d. 842 H), Al-Bisati al-Maaliki (d. 842 H), Abu al-Qaasim al-Barzali (d. 844 H), Muhib ad-Deen Ahmad al-Hanbali (d. 844 H), al-Qaadhi Bakeer al-Hanafi (d. 847 H), Fathullah al-'Ajami (d. 848 H), Muhammad al-Ghamri ash-Shaafi'i (d. 849 H), Al-'Izz al-Qudsi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 850 H), al-Qaadhi al-Qayati ash-Shaafi'i, Moosa ibn Muhammad adh-Dhaja'i ash-Shaafi'i (d. 851 H), Ibn al-Qaadhi Shahbah (d. 851 H), al-Haafidh ibn Hajar al-'Asqalaani (d. 852 H), al-Haafidh Badr ad-Deen al-'Ayni al-Hanafi (d. 855 H), Husayn al-Ahdal ash-Shaafi'i (d. 855 H), 'Ali Al-Qalqashandi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 856 H), Shihaab ad-Deen adh-Dharasi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 856 H), Abu al-Qaasim an-Nawiri al-Maaliki (d. 857 H), 'Imaad ad-Deen al-Kazruni ash-Shaafi'i (d. 860 H), Ibn al-Hamsi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 861 H), Al-Kamaal ibn al-Hummam al-Hanafi (d. 861 H), Al-Ashmuni al-Maaliki (d. 862 H), Ash-Shams al-Balatunusi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 863 H), Ibn Ash-Shammaa' ash-Shaafi'i (d. 863 H), Siraaj ad-Deen al-Hanafi (d. 865 H), al-Qaadhi Ibn ad-Dayri al-Hanafi (d. 867 H), Jamaal ad-Deen ibn Ayyub ash-Shaafi'i (d. 868 H), Ibn Qaraa ash-Shaafi'i (d. 868 H), Saalih al-Bulqini ash-Shaafi'i (d. 868 H), Ibn Falati ash-Shaafi'i (d. 870 H), al-Qaadhi Yahya al-Munawi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 871 H), Ahmad ash-Shumuni al-Hanafi (d. 872 H), al-Qaadhi ibn Hurayz al-Maaliki (d. 873 H), Muhammad al-Kamal ash-Shaafi'i (d. 874 H), al-Qaadhi Ibn al-Imaad al-Hanafi (d. 874 H), Jamaal ad-Deen an-Nashiri ash-Shaafi'i (d. 874 H), al-Qaadhi 'Izz ad-Deen al-Hanbali (d. 876 H), Al-Ameen Al-Aqsara'i al-Hanafi (d. 880 H), Ibn Afeef ad-Deen ash-Shaafi'i (d. 880 H), al-Qaadhi 'Ali an-Nawiri al-Maaliki (d. 882 H), Burhaan ad-Deen al-Biqa'i ash-Shaafi'i (d. 885 H), As-Siraaj Al-Abbadi (d. 885 H), Ibn Abi al-Wafa' ash-Shaafi'i (d. 887 H), Ibn Khaleefah al-Maaliki (d. 889 H), al-Qaadhi Muhib ad-Deen ibn Shahnah al-Hanafi (d. 890 H), Abu Sa'adat al-Bulqini (d. 890 H), 'Ubaydullah as-Samarqandi al-Hanafi (d. 895 H), 'Abd al-Malik as-Sawaji ash-Shaafi'i (d. 896 H), Ibn Kaatib Qa'at adh-Dhahab ash-Shaafi'i (d. 897 H), Ahmad Zarooq al-Maaliki (d. 899 H), and Ibraheem an-Naaji ash-Shaafi'i (d. 900 H).

From the tenth century AH: 'Abd al-Mu'ti al-Muhammadi al-Maaliki, Mullah Ahmad, Hafeed at-Taftazaani, Ahmad ash-Shibli al-Hanbali, Shams ad-Deen as-Sakhaawi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 902 H), Abu Bakr al-'Eedrus ash-Shadhili (d. 914 H), Ibn Fahd al-Makki ash-Shaafi'i (d. 921 H), Shams ad-Deen al-Kafarsoosi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 932 H), Sa'di Jalabi al-Hanafi (d. 945 H), Shams ad-Deen al-Falooji ad-Dimashqi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 952 H), Shams ad-Deen ibn Tuloon al-Hanafi (d. 953 H), Jawi Zadah al-Hanafi (d. 954 H), Ibraheem al-Halabi al-Hanafi (d. 956 H), 'Aarif Muhammad al-Husayni, 'Abd al-Qadir at-Tarabulsi ad-Dimashqi ash-Shaafi'i (d. 962 H), al-Qaadhi 'Abdullah al-Himyari ash-Shaafi'i (d. 972 H), and Ahmad ar-Rumi.

From the eleventh century AH: Mullah 'Ali al-Qaari al-Hanafi (d. 1014 H), Hasan al-Busnawi al-Kaafi al-Hanafi (d. 1024 H), Mar'i ibn Yoosuf al-Karmi al-Hanbali (d. 1033 H), and Ahmad as-Sirhindi al-Hindi al-Hanafi (d. 1034 H).

From the twelfth century AH: Saalih al-Maqbali (d. 1108 H), Muhammad Hayyat as-Sindi (d. 1163 H), Al-Ameer as-San'ani (d. 1182 H), and As-Saffareeni al-Hanbali (d. 1188 H).

These scholars range from being Hanafis, Maalikis, Shaafi'is, Hanbalis, as well as some being Sufis, Ash'aris and Matureedis. So where are you going O Faraz?!! What "predominant view" are you talking about? What admiration and respect do we find in statements of these scholars which you can read in the book [ابن عربي عقيدته وموقف علماء المسلمين منه]?!

So let us illustrate the degree of "respect" and "admiration" Ibn 'Arabi received, consider the words of the learned and virtuous jurist, Imam Ibraheem ibn Muhammad ibn Ibraheem al-Halabi al-Hanafi, author of Multaqa al-Abhar which some scholars consider a relied-upon text.

He accused Ibn 'Arabi being guilty of atheism, heresy, distortion, lying, fabricating falsehoods against Allaah, displaying blatant disrespect toward Him and His prophets, and belittling the status of prophethood. He said that some of his statements lead to shirk, that he openly manifested shirk, that he had a wicked principle concerning unity of being [ittihaad], and that his belief is vile. He said that his sect was composed of innovators, and that he was a partisan of the disbelievers. He also described him as being shameless, stupid, senile, self-contadictory, deceptive, insane, a rambler, an imbecile, foolish, confused, and one with immense ignorance. He also said that he was vile, misguided himself and misguiding others, a man of fantasies and personal whims, dealing in nonsense and myths, while indulging in self-praise, baseless claims, and arrogance. And last of all, al-Halabi said:

May Allaah, the most High, place you in that Fire which you praised, and praised those inside it if he did not repent before his death from these misguidances and nonsensical claims.

And I say to this, we have nothing to indicate Ibn 'Arabi ever repented. And Allaah knows best of his condition.

Mullah 'Ali ibn Sultaan al-Qaari wrote an entire treatsie refuting Ibn 'Arabi and his sect, titled [الرد على القائلين بوحدة الوجود]. What "respect" and "admiration" does this muhaqqiq show? He says:

Know that whoever believes Ibn 'Arabi's creed to be true is a disbeliever by consensus, without dispute. The discussion only concerns the case where his words are interpreted in a way that indicates a sound intention. You have already seen from the interpretations of those who undertook to investigate this matter that there is nothing there that can validly or suitably defend him from blame. Someone may remain who doubts and imagines that there is some possible interpretation, although he is unable to provide such an interpretation. The eminent scholar Ibn al-Muqri explicitly stated, as mentioned earlier, that whoever doubts the disbelief of the Jews, Christians, and the group of Ibn 'Arabi is a disbeliever. This is an obvious matter and a clear ruling. As for one who suspends judgment, he is not excused for doing so. Rather, his suspension of judgment is itself a cause of his disbelief.

And he said:

Therefore, if you are truly a believer and sincere Muslim, do not doubt the disbelief of the group of Ibn 'Arabi, and do not suspend judgment concerning the misguidance of this misguided people and foolish group. If you ask, 'Is it permissible to initiate the greeting of peace to them?' I say: No. Nor should their greeting of peace be returned. Indeed, one should not even say to them, 'And upon you.' For they are worse than the Jews and Christians, and their ruling is that of those who have apostatized from the religion. Know from this that if one of them sneezes and says, 'Praise be to Allaah,' he should not be told, 'May Allaah have mercy upon you.' Whether one should reply, 'May Allaah guide you,' is a matter for discussion. Likewise, when one of them dies, it is not permissible to pray over him. Their previous acts of worship based on their beliefs are invalid, just as their subsequent acts of obedience during the remainder of their lives are invalid.

At the end, he stated:

It is obligatory upon the rulers in the lands of Islam to burn those who hold these corrupt beliefs and futile interpretations, for they are even more impure than the one who claimed that 'Ali was Allaah, whom 'Ali, may Allaah be pleased with him, burned. It is also obligatory to burn their authored books, and it is incumbent upon everyone to clarify the corruption of their opposition and the worthlessness of their hypocrisy. The silence of the scholars and the differences among some opinions have become a cause of this tribulation and all forms of affliction.

If this is the "respect" and "admiration" Faraz Rabbani is referring to, then I agree with it wholeheartedly. I refer the reader to the following book which has discussed Ibn 'Arabi, his beliefs, and what the scholars of Islam said about him, in detail:

→ Ahad Ahadeeth are not accepted in establishing 'Aqeedah

Source: Establishing matters of Aqidah with Hadith Ahad.

I have addressed this topic in the following article: Authority of Ahadeeth al-Ahad in 'Aqeedah

• Fiqh

While researching various topics and legal issues, I began noticing a recurring pattern in a number of the answers I came across from SeekersGuidance. Many things I took issue with appeared to be influenced by liberalism and secularism. It is my assessment that they attempt to accommodate liberal and secular values by using Islam and its principles to justify their desires and whims. In doing so, they distort, reinterpret, and misrepresent rulings and principles in order to arrive at conclusions more acceptable to a liberalized audience.

What I find particularly concerning is that they can be remarkably lax and accommodating when dealing with matters that are prohibited, yet unusually severe and restrictive when it comes to matters of Islam itself, its principles, and adherence to its rulings. It is as if they are making obedience to Islam difficult while making concessions for their desires and values which go against Islam. Such a methodology is dangerous, because Islam should not be reshaped to conform to liberal or secular ideas. Nor should our desires and assumptions be the basis for our following of Islam.

A headsup that my methodology in this entire section is not to answer the question itself, rather my focus is on criticizing and exposing the ignorance and misguidance that the answerers on SeekersMisguidance are spreading through these answers.

→ Polygamy is impermissible, False Conditions added to Polygamy, and Discouraging Polygamy

Sources:

  1. Is Polygamy really Allowed?
  2. Can a Husband Marry a Second Wife Without His First Wife's Permission?
  3. May I Marry A Second Wife If My Wife is Barren?
  4. Is Cheating on One's Spouse Considered a Major Sin in Islam?
  5. A Married Man Wants to Marry Me. What Do I Do?
  6. I Married a Man Whose First Wife Does Not Approve. Do I Divorce Him?

Before I answer these, there is a bit of history to discuss regarding the first source. The most recent snapshot which hosted their answer was on 13th March 2021 (that is the one I have linked). The next snapshot captured by the Wayback Machine (22nd December, 2022) showed that the page was deleted by SeekersGuidance. What is interesting however is that some SeekersGuidance articles still reference this deleted article (see fourth, fifth source).

This can mean either of two things: Faraz Rabbani and Tabraze Azam (the answerer) retracted it, or they deleted it because it was too blatant in showing the kind of agenda they are pushing. What I mean by that is since they wish to push liberal, western, and secular ideals, their answer on this matter was too clear which would warrant criticism and condemnation. So they opted to remove this answer, and push their agenda subtely in similar articles, which they did, as we will see. This is further reinforced by the fact that I am unable to find any kind of retraction for this particular answer. Granted I am not aware much of all social media that SeekersGuidance, Faraz Rabbani or Tabraze Azam use, that is why I am putting out a request to any supporter of SeekersGuidance or other, that if they have a retraction for this answer, share it with me: Contact Me

With that out of the way, I am going to assume my second interpretation is correct, and that they deleted the answer because it was too blatant in showing their agenda. The questioner said:

Question: I am doubting Islam because I have been told that it allows secret marriages to second wives. How is this allowed? Why it is not adultery? Can a divorced women with children have a secret marriages to a man who is married with children meeting up at different places with no second home setup as she is at home with her kids and he is home with his kids and first wife?

The answerer, Tabraze Azam replied

The general ruling for polygamy in our times is that it is impermissible...

Tabraze Azam is the kind of person who is in danger of falling into the people regarding whom Allaah (may He be exalted) said:

وَلَا تَقُولُوا۟ لِمَا تَصِفُ أَلْسِنَتُكُمُ ٱلْكَذِبَ هَـٰذَا حَلَـٰلٌ وَهَـٰذَا حَرَامٌ لِّتَفْتَرُوا۟ عَلَى ٱللَّهِ ٱلْكَذِبَ ۚ إِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ يَفْتَرُونَ عَلَى ٱللَّهِ ٱلْكَذِبَ لَا يُفْلِحُونَ
And say not concerning that which your tongues put forth falsely: "This is lawful and this is forbidden," so as to invent lies against Allâh. Verily, those who invent lies against Allâh will never prosper. [An-Nahl 16:116]

The worst part of this answer - in principle - is the reason he presented behind why polygamy is prohibited. He said:

because of the inevitable harm which comes about from such relationships, particularly amongst those who are not accustomed to such practices.

Had the "Ustadh" simply limited himself to the Quraan, the Sunnah, and Ijmaa' (consensus), that would have been better for him. This 'reason' provided by him can be used to permit any prohibited matter, and prohibit any permitted matter! There is no power nor strength except through Allaah, the Almighty. لا حول ولا قوة إلا بالله العظيم

The answer to this is that polygamy does not necessitate "inevitable harm" as is falsely claimed by this liar. Our question therefore is what does "inevitable harm" refer to, and mean? Someone may say that "inevitable harm" here refers to the part of the question about secret marriages. However, this is not what we are told by the answerer, for he clearly stated that impermissibility is the general ruling in our times.

Without any clarification as to what "inevitable harm" means, we can only assume that perhaps "inevitable harm" refers to the natural feeling of jealousy that women get. If such is the case, then the natural jealousy felt by women for their husbands is not something that is specific to our times, rather it is in their nature, thus has always been the case. Even with the wives of the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him) were not free from it, however that did not serve as a reason to prohibit the Messenger of Allaah (peace be upon him) or those after him from polygamy, this is not an "inevitable harm", it has no bearing to the ruling. (Source)

Or perhaps by "inevitable harm", they mean secret marriages. If that is the case, it cannot serve as a reason for prohibition in general as done by the answerer, for not every marriage is done secretly. So to say they meant secret marriages is not correct.

Or perhaps, the "inevitable harm" mentioned is the harm to their western audience. Those who love, encourage and promote liberalism and secularism could not stand the ruling of polygamy, therefore SeekersGuidance and Faraz Rabbani ran to placate them, so that they are not abandoned by them. If such is the case, they are not fit to guide others, they are misguided people taking themselves into the Fire, and you (the one who willingly follows them) with them.

With all of that out of the way, now we answer these liars on the basis of the Hanafi madhhab. They have tagged their answer as having been answered per Hanafi Fiqh. Thus, one may ask if that is really the case, the answer is no, it is not. They have actively opposed the madhhab, rather than follow it. First of all, there is a well known principle which says:

لا مَساغَ للِاجتِهادِ في مَورِد النَّصِّ
There is no permissibility for Ijtihaad (independent reasoning) in the presence of an explicit text

Shaykh Mufti Abu Lubabah Shah Mansoor stated, explaining this principle in [القواعد الفقهية من مجلة الأحكام العدلية]:

Explanation: Ijtihaad is not permissible regarding a legal issue on which an explicit text (nass) defining its ruling has been conveyed. This is because ijtihaad only applies where no explicit text exists. For example, an explicit text (nass) came prohibiting gambling, therefore, there is no room for ijtihaad to permit it. Or an explicit text (nass) came stating that the mother receives a sixth [of the inheritance] if the deceased has offspring or multiple siblings, thus, ijtihaad is not permitted to grant her more than that.

Therefore, how could the "Ustadh" prohibit what Allaah has explicitly permitted for the believers?! Allaah, may He be exalted, said:

فَٱنكِحُوا۟ مَا طَابَ لَكُم مِّنَ ٱلنِّسَآءِ مَثْنَىٰ وَثُلَـٰثَ وَرُبَـٰعَ ۖ فَإِنْ خِفْتُمْ أَلَّا تَعْدِلُوا۟ فَوَٰحِدَةً
Then marry those that please you of [other] women, two or three or four. But if you fear that you will not be just, then [marry only] ... [An-Nisa 4:3]

The text explicitly allows a man to marry up to four wives at once, and this is consensus among the scholars. (Source)

Shams al-Aimmah as-Sarakhsi said in [المبسوط]:

This contract, according to the majority of scholars, may Allaah Most High have mercy upon them, is Sunnah and recommended.

An-Nasafi stated:

"It (i.e. marriage) is a Sunnah, but when there is strong desire, it becomes necessary.."

Az-Zayla'i said, explaining his statement in [تبيين الحقائق شرح كنز الدقائق]:

That is, marriage is a Sunnah, but when a person experiences intense sexual desire, marriage becomes necessary, so that he is able to protect himself from falling into zinaa (fornication/adultery).

Ibn 'Aabideen said in [رد المحتار]:

His (i.e. al-Haskafi) statement, "It is an emphasized Sunnah according to the sounder opinion", This is what is meant by the view that marriage is recommended. The term mustahabb (recommended) is often used somewhat loosely to refer to a Sunnah.

Now, one may wonder that we know that the Hanafi madhhab says marriage is a Sunnah, so what does the statements of these scholars achieve? Then we answer that unlike some scholars who held it was better to have one wife, the Hanafis do not hold such. Instead, we hold marriage being a Sunnah in general, hence why our scholars recommended not just a single marriage but more marriages as well, based on the wisdoms behind marriage as a whole. Another relevant principle to this discussion is:

المطلق يجري على إطلاقه ما لم يقم دليل التقييد نصا أو دلالة
An unrestricted (absolute) term is to be understood according to its unrestricted meaning unless there is an explicit (text, term) or an indication that restricts it

Shaykh Mufti Abu Lubabah Shah Mansoor said, explaining this principle in [القواعد الفقهية من مجلة الأحكام العدلية]:

Explanation: An absolute (mutlaq) term is a word that applies to all the individuals included in its meaning without specifying any particular one. For example, the word "man" (rajul) can refer to any adult human male. Thus, if I say to you: "Give a man a dirham," whichever adult male human you give the dirham to, you have complied with the command. The restricted (muqayyad) term is a word whose general application is limited by a particular qualification or condition. For example, if a man is described as "white" or "a man in the school," the meaning is restricted to those possessing that qualification. Therefore, an absolute term remains unrestricted unless there is textual evidence (nass) or an indication (dalalah) that restricts it. Once such a restriction is established, its application becomes limited according to the meaning of that restriction.
Examples:

If a person lends something to another person without specifying who may benefit from it, the loan is considered unrestricted. The borrower may use the item in the customary manner himself, and he may also lend it to someone else for use. However, if the owner says, "I have lent this item to you on the condition that you use it yourself," then the loan becomes restricted, and the borrower is not permitted to lend the item to someone else.

If a person authorizes someone to purchase a horse for him without specifying what kind of horse should be purchased, the instruction is considered unrestricted. However, based on the circumstances and the condition of the person giving the authorization, it is understood that the horse should be suitable for his circumstances. If the agent purchases a very expensive, high-quality purebred horse instead, then, according to this example, the horse belongs to the agent rather than the person who authorized the purchase.

Now, you apply this concept onto marriage being a Sunnah, then the rewards for following the Sunnah when one marries, it applies whether it is your first marriage, second, third, fourth and so on. The rewards of following the Sunnah and acting upon it is not limited to merely the first time you marry, but anytime you marry. This increases the reward of polygamy tenfold than marrying only once.

However the Ayah we quoted, it was clear that one who is unable to be just between his wives, should not do polygamy. More detail on what "being unjust" entails will follow later. In the meantime, consider the words of Mahmood al-Alusi, the Mufti of the Hanafis in Baghdad, who stated in [روح المعاني] in explanation of the Ayah we quoted:

Some of them said: Indeed, this also contains an indication that having more than one wife is recommended for someone who does not fear being unable to maintain justice between them. This is because Allaah, Glorified is He, mentioned the option of taking additional wives first, while He made restricting oneself to one wife contingent upon fearing that one may not be able to maintain justice.

Imam Abu Bakr al-Jassas said in his [أحكام القرآن] on the same Ayah:

As for His statement, Most High, 'two, three, and four', this is permission for two, if he wishes; three, if he wishes; or four, if he wishes. He is given the choice regarding which of these numbers he wishes to combine. He said: 'If he fears that he will not be just, he should limit himself from four to three. If he fears that he will not be just, he should limit himself from three to two. If he fears that he will not be just between the two, he should limit himself to one.

Consider the words of Al-Jassas carefully. If he fears he cannot be just with four, he limits himself to three. If he cannot be just to three, he limits himself to two, and if he cannot be just with two, he limits himself to one. Therefore, the original ruling from his words indicate towards polygamy, and that you should only take one if you cannot be just with more.

Abu Bakr al-Kasani in [بدائع الصنائع] stated:

The basis for this [i.e. obligation of justice between women regarding rights] is His statement:
'But if you fear that you will not deal justly, then [marry only] one.' [an-Nisa 4:3]
This comes immediately after His statement, Exalted is He:
'Then marry those that please you of [other] women, two, three, or four.' [an-Nisa 4:3]
Meaning: If you fear that you will not deal justly with regard to the division of time and maintenance when marrying two, three, or four women, then marry only one. He, the Exalted and Praised, encouraged marrying only one when there is a fear of failing to maintain justice by marrying additional wives....

Al-Kasani's words hold similar meanign to al-Jassas's. Further more, from the contemporaries, similar is stated by Mufti Wali Hasan at-Tonki (d. 1995 CE), who was one of the Hanafi scholars in al-Hind. He said in one of his books:

Therefore, polygamy is not merely permissible in an absolute sense... rather, marrying more than one wife is recommended (mustahabb), because Allaah Almighty originally commanded it as the primary option and made restricting oneself to a single wife dependent on a specific condition—namely, the inability to maintain justice.

The Pakistani Hanafi scholar, Mufti Tariq Masood transmitted this in his book [ایک سے زائد شادیوں کی ضرورت کیوں؟].

In general for those who understand Urdu, this book is relevant to the topic. it's name translates to, "Why the need for polygamy?" For those who wish to read it in its entirety and are able to do so, I'd highly recommend it. [PDF]

Moving onto the second source, then this answer is very similar to the first. The question put forth in the second source is:

Question: Can a husband marry a second wife without his first wife’s permission?

Faraz replies:

The fatwa of major Arab and Indo-Pak scholars is that it is generally wrong and unwise in our times to marry a second wife, without consulting wise and knowledgeable scholars (even though it is in itself permitted)

First, we address this aspect. We have already discussed in great length that there is nothing wrong with polygamy in the sharee'ah, and the Hanafi madhhab views it as recommended, and only commands to taking one wife when he cannot be just to more than one.

Second, who are these supposed "major arab and indo-pak scholars" that Faraz is talking about? Why did he not quote from them so we could also read their words? Maybe I can present a major Indo-Pak scholar instead, and what he stated on this matter: Mufti Muhammad Shafee' al-'Uthmaani, the former grand mufti of Pakistan. He was undoubtedly one of the major Indo-Pak scholars. He stated in his tafseer [Ma'arif al-Quraan]:

Polygamy and its currency before Islam
That one man could have more than one wife was something considered permissible in all religions of the world even before the advent of Islam. The custom prevailed in Arabia, India, Iran, Egypt, and Babylon and among peoples elsewhere. Its natural validity cannot be denied even to this day. The Europeans of the present age tried to break away from the practice of their predecessors and made multiplicity of marriage impermissible. It resulted in the multiplicity of concubines and girl-friends retained out of wedlock. It was the validity of the natural that there has been a consistent opinion bank in the West (though not so effective) which recognizes the efficacy of plurality of marriage. Davenport, the well-known Christian writer has deduced from the Bible that plurality of wives is not only favourable but is a source of blessing from God. Others such as Father Nixon, John Milton and Isac Taylor have supported this view strongly. Similarly, Vedic teachings permit unlimited number of wives, even in tens and thirteens and twenty sevens, at one time. Shri Krishna, a highly respected deity among Hindus, had hundreds of wives.
The truth of the matter is that a religion or law which aims to establish an infra-structure of against adultery, it serves as a remedial approach to the problem of comparatively larger female population in some areas as compared to that of men. If such permission was not granted, mistresses and prostitutes will proliferate. This is why nations which do not permit plurality of wives must live in. rampant adultery (calling it 'free sex' hardly changes the reality). Even in our own time, if we look at the state of nations in Europe and America, we will see that they look down on what they call polygamy and put a ban on plurality of wives, but they permit a man to practice adultery with as many women as he can get under the cover of 'friendship', (and unlimited are the euphemisms invented to give it other names, such as, 'relationship', 'affair', 'consenting adults', 'union', 'partner' to get around the ban). Saying no to marriage and yes to adultery is certainly very strange!

How relevant is the saying of the shaykh:

The Europeans of the present age tried to break away from the practice of their predecessors and made multiplicity of marriage impermissible

How interesting to see Faraz Rabbani following in the steps of the Europeans (and Americans) who tried to argue against polygamy, and conjured up emotional responses against the rulings of the revelation. The predecessor of Faraz Rabbani on this issue are Europeans! So let the one who fears His Lord take heed.

Faraz Rabbani continues on, listing the reasons why polygamy is "wrong" and "unwise", repeating rhetoric of the Europeans (either knowingly or unknowingly):

because of the harm and mess that inevitably results:

a) the harm to the first wife;

b) the troubles with the second wife when the first is upset;

c) the harm of not giving both their legal, emotional, and material rights;

d) the harm to family relations;

e) and, also vitally, the harm to one’s children…

The first reason, we are again left to only guess and wonder what "harm to the first wife" means. Are these people allergic to defining vague and ambiguous terms to make it clear for the reader? I have started to be become suspicious that they intentionally do not define these terms, because by leaving it as vague, anyone can come across their articles, and justify any kind of bogus harm (even if said "harm" is actually just liberal rhetoric), and attribute it to them. Either this is the reason, or Faraz Rabbani is not fit to be answering questions. He leaves behind more questions than answers, spreading confusion and ambiguity in matters where Islam is clear.

The second reason, they say the first wife being upset is a reason it is "unwise" and "wrong" to marry another. Did these people who claim to have studied under "leading Hanafi fuqaha'" not learn anything? Did they not go through studies of the major hadeeth books, and see instances of the wives of the Prophet (peace be upon him) being upset and jealous!? It is becoming quite apparent that they did not. The "first wife being upset" is merely another way to say the natural jealousy that women get over their husbands. This jealousy is natural for them, and no previous scholar has stated what these liars put forth. However know well that his predecessors, the Europeans and Americans are the ones who make such kinds of argument.

As for the third reason, once again, it is vague and we have no idea what "legal" "emotional" and "material rights" mean. Wouldn't "legal rights" already have "emotional" and "material" rights if it came from Islam? This inconsistency in defining what exactly each "right" means tells us enough, which is by these "rights", Faraz Rabbani does not mean the shar'i rights that are necessary upon a husband. Rather, these are additional "rights", which likely come from liberalism. In Islam, there are no such terms as the ones he used.

Instead, Islam has the term [النفقة] which is derived from spending (الإنفاق), and it refers to providing something with what is necessary for its continued existence, as per [قواعد الفقه للبركتي ص ٢٥٨]. In shar'i terms, this refers to the spending of the husband over his wife, which we will refer to as "maintenance". Once we have defined it, we go forward as to what "justice" (عدل) in the Ayah refers to. Ibn 'Aabideen stated in [رد المحتار]:

You should know that the 'justice' mentioned in his statement means not being unjust, rather than making things equal, because equality is not required in matters of maintenance in all circumstances. In al-Bahr: He said in al-Badaa'i: It is necessary upon him to treat the two free women and the two slave women equally with regard to food, drink, clothing, accommodation, and spending the night with them. Al-Walwaliji likewise mentioned this..
The correct position is that this applies according to the opinion of those who consider the man's condition alone when determining maintenance. As for the relied-upon opinion, which considers the condition of both the husband and wife, then this is not the case. One of the two women may be wealthy while the other is poor, so equal maintenance between them is not absolutely required

After understanding this detail, know that in the case of having multiple wives, equality is necessary in three things. Among these, complete equality is unconditionally obligatory in two things. Those three things are:

1- Additional Gifts: That is, apart from the necessary basic maintenance, extra pocket money, additional clothes, or extra gifts given on occasion of Eid, marriage, or any other happy event without any request from the wife. Apart from necessary maintenance, extra expenses, gifts, or clothing are not mandatory on the husband himself. However, if someone among multiple wives gives additional gifts to one wife, it then becomes mandatory upon him to give the other wife an equivalent gift or item of appropriate value. If he does not do so, he will commit the sin of injustice and oppression. A person who strongly fears that he will not be able to maintain equality among multiple wives in this matter, marrying a second time is forbidden for him.

2- Spending the Night: If a person has two wives, the number of nights he spends with one wife, he is required to spend an equal number of nights with the other wife as well. For instance, if he spends one month with one wife, it becomes mandatory to spend one month with the other wife. If he spends a week with one wife, he must spend a week with the other wife. In short, although it was not mandatory on the husband himself to spend a specific number of nights with his wife, rather this depends on the wife's need and demand. In the case of two marriages, it becomes mandatory to spend as many nights with one wife as spent with the other, even if the other wife does not require it. If a person does not maintain equality in spending nights, he will commit severe oppression and sin. A person who strongly fears that he will not be able to maintain equality among wives in this matter, marrying a second time is forbidden and impermissible for him.

3- Necessary Maintenance: In Fiqh, maintenance (Nafaqah) consists of three things: appropriate food, clothing and housing. Meaning: along with essential household amenities, providing the wife with at least one separate room where no one else enters except the husband. However, what standard constitutes "appropriate food," "appropriate clothing," and "appropriate housing"? The Sharee'ah has left its determination to customs ('Urf). Regarding this, both the husband's financial capability and his wife's family background are taken into account. That is, on one hand, the husband's financial capacity is considered, and on the other hand, the standard of food, clothing, and housing the wife was accustomed to in her parents' home is considered. Keeping both factors in mind, appropriate food, clothing, and housing are determined. Complete equality in this maintenance is mandatory in the scenario where each wife among multiple wives belongs to similar family backgrounds or financial statuses prior to marriage. But when wives come from different backgrounds with different financial statuses, the husband is not required to provide them with identical standards of food and housing. Instead, each wife's maintenance must be aligned with the lifestyle she was accustomed to at her parents' house.

These detailed rulings written regarding justice are according to the opinion of the Hanafi madhhab upon which fatwa is given. However, many other scholars have cautioned that in a polygamous marriage, as far as one has capacity, one should strive to maintain equality in every matter. Since maintaining equality among multiple wives is strongly emphasized in clear texts of the Quraan and the Sunnah, caution dictates that in speaking, conversation, and times spent together, one should maintain equality to the best of one's ability. In short, one should not do anything that makes one wife feel that her husband has an extraordinary inclination toward the other wife, making her feel inferior. According to these scholars, such behavior is considered injustice, and the Sharee'ah does not encourage such injustice. Therefore, if someone provides a poor wife with the same standard of maintenance as a wealthy wife, or maintains equality in everything within his capability without leaving any stone unturned, his action - being based on caution - will certainly be commendable. However, since love is an involuntary emotion, and physical intimacy is related to natural inclination and desire, equality in these two matters is not necessary.

As for the fourth and fifth reasons, these are similar to the reasons addressed above, where ambuigity and vagueness is perhaps intentional to allow people to conjure up whatever they wish inside their minds, and use his article to justify it. The invalidity of polygamy cannot be argued based on so-called "harms" which are unclear, undefined, and perhaps not even considered "harm" per the sharee'ah. If the disbelievers argue that getting less sleep so that one may pray Tahajjud is "harmful", can someone from the Muslims come along and say, "since Tahajjud brings harm by making one get less sleep, it is wrong and unwise to pray Tahajjud"? According to the principles and methodology that Faraz Rabbani relies on - as apparent to us -, this would be perfectly fine.

Now we move onto answering the third source. The questioner is a brother who says:

I have been married for a couple of years now. It happens that my wife is infertile. Her infertility existed before the marriage and it is probably due to an event that happened when she was a kid, she however told me she was never aware it could possibly make her infertile. I really want to have biological children.

I have three questions, first, what are the process/conditions of getting married to a second wife, shall my wife give her approval? Second, can the second wife be located abroad if the country where I currently live in does not allow polygamy? Third, is infertility considered as a fault that can enable divorce?

The answerer is a woman (???) named Shazia Ahmad.

You “could marry” a second wife in order to have children...

The only reason I can think of 'could marry' being under quotation marks is because while she cannot outright reject it, she is subtly trying to push the agenda that marrying another wife is something 'bad' and 'should be avoided', even though in the case of the brother, it is a legitimate solution. She immediately says after that:

but you will be dealing with the huge burden of having two wives and not being able to see your children as often as if you only had one wife, let alone the jealousy and other problems that arise. Of course, if you live in a country where polygamy is illegal, it would be even more difficult. The harm that it would cause to your first wife is immeasurable because it is Allah’s decree to give children or not, it is not her fault at all, yet you would be punishing her. There are many young healthy people who are also unable to have children.

She starts scaring the brother with "issues" and "problems" which may not even exist in his life! And look at their repetitivity in mentioning "jealousy" as if it is a problem. If jealousy's mere existence means it is problematic, then their understanding would imply the marriages of the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him), the Companions, the Successors (Tabi'een), and those after them were problematic, because there is no doubt some of their wives also felt jealous when they took others as wives. We've already quoted an article detailing out how the wives of the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him) would get jealous. It is natural for them to be jealous, but no shar'i text or scholarly statement claims it is an obstacle.

More so, the claim that doing so will be "punishing" the first wife assumes a negative stance with regard to the husband's choice. If Allaah allows the man to marry another woman, it does not automatically make him "punishing" the first wife if she is likely to become sad or have problems with such a decision. It is true that the lack of children is the decree of Allaah, and the first wife is not to blame for this. However, this does not make the husband's decision punishing to her, nor does it drop his own right to have children. Imam as-Sarakhsi in [المبسوط] said, explaining the benefits of marriage:

Among them is increasing the servants of Allaah Most High and the Ummah of the Messenger (peace and blessings upon him) and thereby fulfilling the Messenger's (peace and blessings upon him) desire to have a large Ummah as he said: "Marry and reproduce and increase in number, for I will boast of your numbers before the nations on the Day of Resurrection." The reason for this is that the continuation which Allaah has decreed is connected to it until its appointed time. Allaah Most High has decreed that the world will remain until the establishment of the Hour, and through reproduction this continuation takes place.

Therefore, the "advice" given by the "Ustadhah" is:

I recommend that you look for another suitable alternative for your happiness and come to peace with what Allah has decreed for you.

How this "Ustadhah" turns the issue around from the issue being found in the brother's wife to the brother, Allaah is sought for help for this deception. We have went in great detail about polygamy being a Sunnah, and now we have cited from As-Sarakhsi about how it fulfills the objectives of the Sharee'ah. Does this "ustadhah" care about what the Sharee'ah considers its objectives? No, her objectives are firmly rooted in the liberal agenda they push. Allaah did not decree infertility for the brother, so her "advice" being to be at "peace with what Allaah decreed" is nothing but diverting the brother from the solution which the Sharee'ah and actual scholars of this religion would recommend to him. He would only be dissuaded from polygamy if he held he could not do justice between two wives. Otherwise, this "Ustadhah" has no right to discourage from something through which the Sharee'ah's objectives are fulfilled.

And if one wonders why I wrote "(???)" when I took her name here, that is because it has been established that women are naturally jealous of the other wives of her husband. So, I am amazed as to why in the world Rabbani thought it was appropriate for this "Ustadhah" to give "advice" to a brother about polygamy. Is it really a surprise this woman is discouraging and dissuading this brother from a solution that may solve his problem? And Subhan Allaah, on what basis except following their desires and whims. Know, that there is no shar'i issue with a woman answering such a question. However, when it is clear she is giving unsound, baseless advice which stems from her emotions, with arguments that suits the disbelievers more (i.e. due to the western influence), she should be kept far away from this topic. But, it does not matter in this case, for the women and the men of SeekersMisguidance are both tools who spread the disease of liberalism.

The fourth source is yet again answered by a woman ("Ustadhah" Raidah ) on a matter which she should not be giving advice on. The question is from a sister who says:

My husband and I were having issues in our marriage. It came to a point where my husband left. I have recently discovered that he has been speaking to another woman in regards to marriage, and found her to be unsuitable. When I found out about this, I tried to reconcile with him. He became defensive and said that he can have up to four wives. Then he stated that he is not interested in marrying her. Has he cheated on me?

So a very precarious issue that requires a careful balance, making it important to understand the issue more in depth. These kinds of issues that arise between spouses need to be taken care of delicately, requiring a need to know both sides to have a full picture of the issue, so surely the "Ustadhah" then asked some more details, before sh-

Infidelity

Your husband going behind your back and speaking about marriage to another woman is already a form of emotional infidelity. I pray that Allah heals your heartbreak. In our modern age, scholars are strongly opposed to polygamy due to the harm caused.

There are genuinely no words to describe the absolute and complete disregard for the Sharee'ah, its terms, and I question how these people were even selected to give councel and advice to people.

Consider the saying of Shaykh al-Barkati in [قواعد الفقه للبركتي - ادب المفتي ص ٢٨٧]:

Issue: In this present age, the duty upon the mufti is to exert the utmost effort in clarifying the answer due to the prevalence of ignorance. He should not answer in vague or unrestricted terms, nor should he resort to riddles or ambiguous phrasing. Instead, he should carefully consider the question, and whenever the matter calls for a detailed answer, he should provide one, addressing each point precisely.

Is this what we see from these individuals on SeekersGuidance? No, rather we see the complete opposite. Their answers are ambiguous and vague, leaving behind more questions than answers, they do not consider each point, they do not go into detail about matters which should in principle leave no confusion behind. It is as if they just decided one day to start giving answers without any due consideration to the how, the why, the when, and the where. How to give an answer? They do not know. Why are they answering something when they do not know the how? I don't know. When did they start doing it? I have absolutely no idea. Where did they learn the how? They likely didn't.

So now we have another "ustadhah" giving ridiculous, nonsensical answers. What even is "emotional infidelity"?! From what is apparent to us, this is the "Ustadhah" calling pursuing the Sunnah as "emotional infidelity", simply because the sister was not informed. First, we have no idea what the issue between the sister and the husband was, but just because the husband is pursuing another potential for a wife, that itself is not problematic, nor an issue according to the Sharee'ah, this so-called "Ustadhah" using an amibigous term with no shar'i definition for it attacking him for it is not correct nor appropriate. And later I glanced downwards, and saw that the tags to the answer were cheating, abusive husband, polygamy. Allaah is sought for help, this "Ustadhah" is undoubtedly the worst of them all, since we're not done yet.

Fifth source is also a sister, however before I share the question and answer, let us discuss the issue of ill assumption without evidence. Allaah, may He be exalted, said:

يَـٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوا۟ ٱجْتَنِبُوا۟ كَثِيرًا مِّنَ ٱلظَّنِّ إِنَّ بَعْضَ ٱلظَّنِّ إِثْمٌ ۖ
O you who have believed, avoid much [negative] assumption. Indeed, some assumption is sin... [Al-Hujuraat 49:11]

Imam Ibn Katheer said in [تفسير ابن كثير]:

The Prohibition of Unfounded Suspicion

Allaah the Exalted forbids His faithful servants from being suspicious, which includes having doubts and suspicions about the conduct of one's family, relatives and other people in general. Therefore, Muslims are to avoid suspicion without foundation.

Imam At-Tabari said in [تفسير الطبري]:

Allaah Most High says, explaining this verse, O you who believe in Allaah and His Messenger, do not indulge in much suspicion concerning the believers, meaning that you should not think badly of them, for the one who merely suspects is not necessarily correct. Allaah, Glorious and Exalted is He, said:
{Avoid much suspicion}
and He did not say, "Avoid all suspicion," because Allaah has permitted the believers to think well of one another. He said:
{Why, when you heard it, did the believing men and believing women not think good of one another and say, This is an obvious falsehood?}
Thus, Allaah, Glorious and Exalted is He, permitted the believers to think well of one another and to say so, even when they were not certain that what they said about them was actually true.

From [موسوعة التفسير المأثور]:

On the authority of 'Abdullah ibn 'Abbas regarding His saying: "O you who have believed, avoid much [negative] assumption," he said: Allaah forbade the believer from thinking ill of the believer.

Al-Hasan al-Basri said: "O you who have believed, avoid much [negative] assumption. Indeed, some assumption is sin." If you think well of your Muslim brother, you will be rewarded, and if you think ill of him, you will be sinful.

Muqaatil ibn Sulayman said: "O you who have believed, avoid much [negative] assumption." He says: Do not act on assumptions. This is because a man may hear something from his brother that he does not intend to harm, or he may enter a place where he does not intend to harm, but his Muslim brother sees it or hears it and assumes something bad about him. There is no harm in this as long as he does not speak of it. But if he does speak of it, he sins. This is what is meant by His saying: "Indeed, some assumption is a sin."

It is reported from the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings upon him) said: "Avoid suspicion, for suspicion is the gravest lie in talk." Narrated by Al-Bukhaari (5143) and Muslim (2563).

In this hadeeth, the Prophet ﷺ forbids and warns against some of the things that lead to such division, enmity, and hatred. He warned against suspicion, which is an accusation that enters the heart without evidence - meaning having evil thoughts about Muslims and speaking about reports that have not been verified. He said, "Indeed, suspicion is the most false of speech," meaning that falsehood occurs more frequently in suspicion than it does in speech. It has also been said that what is meant by "the most false of speech" is inner speech, because it results from Shaytaan casting thoughts into a person's mind. It has also been said that the sin of this falsehood is greater than the sin of explicitly false speech, or that falsehood occurs more frequently in matters that are merely suspected than in matters that are certain.

(Source)

Now, the question of the sister is:

A married man wants to marry me. His first marriage was arranged by his parents, he has a young son, and his parents would disapprove because I am African and he is Indian. What do I do?

The answerer is the same "Ustadhah" Raidah, and she says:

Secrecy

Dear sister, I am very concerned for you. Please speak to your parents, and seek their counsel. I would imagine that they would be very unhappy to hear about you being a secret second wife. You need to accept that the man you love is bound by very strong cultural beliefs, none of which work in your favour.
Parents

Parents who resort to emotional blackmail, control tactics and so on to manipulate the lives of their children often do so out of fear. Please accept that this is the reality of his parents, and it is unlikely to change.
Character

The man you want to marry already has a wife, a son, and he wishes to marry you knowing that it would devastate his parents. What does that tell you about his level of commitment to honouring his parents, his wife, and being a good example to his child?It is easy for him to be kind and protective to you now, while you are courting. The truth of his character lies in how he will treat you when you are married, far away, and without the support and blessing of your family and in-laws.

Subhan Allaah, how did this woman extract ALL OF THIS from:

A married man wants to marry me. His first marriage was arranged by his parents, he has a young son, and his parents would disapprove because I am African and he is Indian. What do I do?

By Allaah, this woman is on the limits of transgression and slander, and based on what? Nothing but assumption!! From the book [الكبائر] of Adh-Dhahabi which lists out seventy major sins, I counted three major sins this so-called "Ustadhah" may have committed. Namely: telling lies (30th), hurting or reviling Muslims (53rd), and harming the servants of Allaah (54th). Then you realize that she may have committed all three against three Muslims (the parents, and the brother who proposed), that multiplies the amount of sin one would get. لا حول ولا قوة إلا بالله والله المستعان

I also checked the Wayback machine in case more information was in the question, but was removed. Though it seems there is not. This ghaawiyah has looked into the hearts of these three individuals, and found out every single evil and sin in them, questioning their religious commitment, their piety, righteousness, and accusing them of that no Muslim should be accused of.

Sixth source, the questioner is yet again a sister who says:

I met a man, he told me that he is married but nevertheless he proposed to me. I accepted. Since we got married, I have been very unhappy.My husband’s first wife doesn’t accept our marriage and requires him to divorce me. My husband is very kind with me and also respectful, but I just cannot bear this situation anymore. Is divorce the best solution?

Once again, we have the ghaawiyah answering. She replies:

You are in a difficult situation. On one hand, you are already married to a man who is good to you. On the other hand, you both got married knowing that his first wife disapproves. The guilt that you feel now is a natural consequence of your decision. Now the question is whether or not you are able to live well in spite of this guilt. 1) accept your feelings of guilt, make space for them, and strive to make the most of your marriage regardless. 2) accept that it is too difficult for you to deal with your guilt, and ask your husband for a divorce.

Someone inform this ghaawiyah that the first wife's disapproval has no legal weight on the marriage between the sister and the brother. This is not her concern, and she should not ask her husband to divorce the second wife, this is impermissible which is explicitly narrated.

It was narrated that Abu Hurayrah (may Allaah be please with him) said: The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “It is not permissible for a woman to demand her sister’s divorce so that she may take her place and get married; she cannot have more than what is decreed for her.” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 5144; Muslim, 1413).

According to another version, the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) forbade women to stipulate (in the marriage contract) that their sister be divorced. (Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 2577). Al-Bukhaari included this hadeeth in a chapter entitled “Marriage conditions which are not permissible.”
Ibn al-Qayyim (may Allaah have mercy on him) said: the ruling of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) indicates that it is haraam for a woman to stipulate that her sister be divorced, and that the husband is not obliged to fulfil this condition. (Zaad al-Ma’aad, 5/107).

Al-Haafidh Ibn Hajar said: The apparent meaning of the phrase “it is not permitted” is that this is forbidden. This is to be understood as being the rule so long as there is no reason to allow that, such as there being some suspicion concerning the woman which implies that she should not remain married to the husband. The woman (the new wife) may suggest that to the husband by way of advice only or so as to avoid harm that either party may cause to the other.

Ibn Battaal said: Saying that it is not permitted clearly means that it is forbidden, but that does not necessarily mean that the marriage is annulled, rather it is to emphasize that the woman (the new wife) should not demand that he divorce the other wife. She should be content with that which Allaah has decreed for her. (al-Fath, 9/274)

Al-Nawawi said: the meaning of this hadeeth is that it is not permitted for a non-mahram woman to ask the man to divorce his wife and to marry her so that she becomes the only one on whom he spends, whom treats kindly, has intercourse with, etc, as the divorced woman used to be. Sharh Muslim, 9/193

(Source)

The jurists agreed that a condition that contradicts what the contract itself entails is invalid, such as stipulating that the wife is not entitled to a dowry or maintenance. Likewise, a condition that conflicts with the general principles of Islamic law, or conflicts with a specific legal text, is invalid; for example, if a woman stipulates that her co-wife be divorced, based on the Prophet's (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) statement: "A woman should not ask for the divorce of her sister so that she may take over her dish."

(Source)

So we see that the first wife is opposing the Sunnah of the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him) and consensus of the jurists, she is actively sinning by asking her husband to divorce the sister who asked the question, so is this the aspect this ghaawiyah focuses on? Of course not. In her bias and perhaps hatred for polygamy, she tries to deceive the sister. Trying to guilt-trip her into getting a divorce from her husband

I think this section is sufficient to demonstrate the hatred I suspect, the bias, and the many other issues present in SeekersMisguidance when it comes to polygamy. Whether it is disregarding the madhhaib when it suits them, abandoning established shar'i terminology when they have nothing to manipulate or distort. And when they do none of that, they end up committing major sins in an attempt to turn people away from the commands and rulings of Allaah.

→ Inaccurate representation of Qisas between parents and children

Source: Is it True That Parents Cannot Be Executed for Killing Their Children?

The question asked was:

Given recent news items from a Muslim country, where a father was given minor punishment for killing his own daughter: Is it true that parents cannot be executed for killing their children?

Faraz Rabbani answers:

This is not accurate. The prescribed (hadd) punishments cannot be applied to crimes within immediate family, but discretionary punishments (even potentially capital punishments, according to some jurists) can and do apply.

And later on, he says:

Why not apply the prescribed punishments with immediate family?

Thus, it is established in Prophetic teachings that immediate family aren’t given capital punishments for killings–as this has many subsequent harms (consider, for example, the impact on other children, parents, etc), and can make things worse for those already affected.

Refutation to Faraz is divided into three parts. As for the first, how does this man claim to have "learned" under "leading Hanafi fuqaha'" when he does not recognize the difference between Qisaas and Hadd?! From [الموسوعة الفقهية]:

The difference between Qisaas and Hudood:

In crimes involving Qisas (retaliatory punishment), the right belongs to the victim's heirs if the victim has died, and to the victim himself if he is still alive, with regard to carrying out the Qisas or pardoning the offender. The ruler's role is to enforce their request.

As for Hudud (fixed punishments), the matter belongs to the ruler. Once the case reaches him, it is not permissible to waive the punishment. Crimes involving Qisas, however, may be pardoned in exchange for compensation, such as diyah (blood money), or pardoned without any compensation. As for Hudud, it is never permissible to pardon them or intercede on behalf of the offender, whether in exchange for compensation or without compensation.

The question asked was about Qisaas, however Faraz Rabbani started talking about Hudood. While Qisaas is a similar and related word to Hadd, they are not the same thing.

As for the second, how does Faraz Rabbani claim it is not accurate, when it is known that the parent is not killed for killing their children (i.e. There is no Qisaas), due to the saying of the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him), "The father does not suffer retaliation for [killing] the son." In another version, it says: "The father is not killed for the son." This is the view of the four madhhaib, except Maalik made an exception in if the father slaughtered his son.

It was narrated by Ahmad in al-Musnad (346), Ibn Maajah (662), at-Tirmidhi (1400), ad-Daraqutni in his Sunan (3/140), al-Bayhaqi (8/72), Ibn al-Jaarood (788), and Ibn 'Abd al-Barr in at-Tamheed (23/441). Ibn 'Abd al-Barr said:

It is a well-known hadeeth among the scholars of the Hijaz and Iraq, widely transmitted among them. Its fame, acceptance, and practice renders a chain of narration unnecessary, to the point that providing a chain of narration for such a well-known hadeeth would be an unnecessary burden..

Similar was stated by At-Tirmidhi who said after narrating (1399):

The established practice among scholars is that if a father kills his son, he is not executed in retaliation, and if he falsely accuses his son (of zina), he is not punished.

The reason for this is due to doubt that is introduced concerning the application of Qisaas (retaliatory punishment) against the father due to the hadeeth of the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him) who said, "You and your wealth belong to your father." Narrated by Ibn Maajah (4491), At-Tabarani in al-Awsat (3534), and At-Tahaawi in Sharh Ma'ni al-Aathar (5742). It was transmitted through many chains and is authentic. Because this legal doubt is introduced, there can be no Qisaas.

It was also stated it is due to the commands requiring kindness and good treatment toward parents, which prevent Qisaas from being carried out against them. The father was the cause of bringing his child into existence, so the son should not be the cause of his execution. So the father is not killed in retaliation for killing his son, however he is liable to pay the Diyah (blood money).

Since Faraz Rabbani answered this and tagged it under "Hanafi Fiqh", then we will cite some of the Hanafis on this issue. A reminder that the question was, "is it true parents cannot be executed for killing their children?" The question is clearly referring to Qisaas, and even referenced an event which fits the bill. To this question, Faraz Rabbani replied by saying "it was not accurate", meaning it was not accurate to say that parents cannot be executed for killing their children.

Imam as-Sarakhsi in [المبسوط] stated:

The father is not included in this ruling when he kills his son, because according to us, the reason Qisaas is not obligatory upon him is not the existence of a doubt concerning the son's blood. Rather, it is because the special status of fatherhood prevents the child from being considered one against whom Qisaas may be exacted on behalf of the father, just as it prevents him from being legally killed, even if the father's blood is considered permissible to shed because he is an apostate, a combatant, or an adulterer, and he is married...

Imam Abu Bakr al-Kasani in his [بدائع الصنائع] said:

As for the conditions relating to the person who was killed, there are three types. The first is that the victim must not be a part of the killer himself. Thus, if a father kills his child, there is no Qisaas against him. The same applies to the grandfather, the father's father or the mother's father, even if he is further removed in the lineage. Likewise, if a man kills his grandchild, however far down the lineage, there is no Qisaas. The same applies to a mother if she kills her child, or to the maternal grandmother or paternal grandmother if she kills her grandchild.

He also said:

A child is subject to Qisaas for killing a parent, based on the general texts concerning Qisaas, without distinction. The parent is then excluded from those general texts by an explicit, specific textual proof, while the child remains included under the general rule.

Burhan ad-Deen al-Marghinaani in [الهداية] stated:

(A man is not killed in retaliation for killing his son) based on the statement of the Prophet ﷺ: "The father does not suffer retaliation for [killing] the son."... This is also because the parent is the cause of the child's existence and preservation, so it is inconceivable that he should be entitled to bring about his destruction. For this reason, he is not permitted to kill his father, even if he finds him among the ranks of the enemy fighting, or committing adultery while being married. The right of retaliation belongs to the victim, and then passes to the victim's heir. The paternal or maternal grandfather, however high in lineage, is treated in this matter like the father. Likewise, the mother and the grandmother, whether through the father's or mother's side, whether near or distant, are treated likewise, for the reason we have explained. The child, however, is killed in retaliation for killing the parent, since there is no impediment preventing retaliation.

So what exactly is inaccurate in the statement "parents are not killed for killing their children"? Discretionary punishments although it could reach being killed, it cannot be applied on this specific matter anyways since the underlying reason behind why Qisaas was dropped will still be found in the discretionary punishment. Qisaas was not dropped for giggles or because we felt like it.

This brings us to the third part. Faraz Rabbani said:

The prescribed (hadd) punishments cannot be applied to crimes within immediate family, but discretionary punishments (even potentially capital punishments, according to some jurists) can and do apply.

And he said:

Thus, it is established in Prophetic teachings that immediate family aren’t given capital punishments for killings–as this has many subsequent harms (consider, for example, the impact on other children, parents, etc), and can make things worse for those already affected.

According to Merriam-Webster, "immediate family" means:

a person's parents, brothers and sisters, husband or wife, and children

Since the question is clearly about parents, it was not appropriate for Faraz Rabbani to use the word "immediate family" as the dropping of Qisaas only occurs when a parent (father or mother), no matter how high in lineage, kills their child, no matter how low in lineage. Otherwise in principle, Qisaas can still occur between "immediate family". As for Hudood, they can occur as well, but following the same principle in Qisaas when it comes to parents and children.

To conclude, I honestly have no idea why Faraz Rabbani answered the question this way. He could have been truthful, used proper terminology, and end with a simple, "Yes, parents cannot be executed for killing their children", quoting the evidence, the reasoning which our Fuqaha' mentioned, and finishing with an "Allaah knows best." Instead, we get this nonsense.

→ Inaccurate answer on listening to music

Source: Is listening to music haram?

Once again, there is no specific question here, but the question itself gives us enough idea. The answer is written by Yoosuf Welch, and tagged under Hanafi Fiqh. I will point out that generally, this answer is much better than the others we discussed. However, there are still issues. First, Yoosuf said:

Music, according to the majority view, is prohibited with the exception of singing that does not contain any external illicit factors (described below). [Ibn ‘Abidin, Radd al-Muhtar]

This is unfortunately very common among these people when it comes to the issue of music. They present the matter as if it is a difference of opinion, as if even though the majority opinion is the 'one to take' (according to them), they still open the gates for people arguing, "well since it's a difference of opinion, I can take the minor opinion!"

This is particularly problematic as they have tagged the answer per "Hanafi Fiqh". I have already written an entire article citing the words of twenty five scholars of the madhhab declaring music to be prohibited. You can check that out here: Ruling of Music in the Hanafi Madhhab

I said in the introduction:

I have previously written a PDF titled, "The Verdict On Music According To The Scholars Of Islam", in which I have relied upon the sources of the Sharee'ah (The Quraan, the Sunnah, Ijmaa') as well as the views of all four madhhaib and sayings of the righteous generations to show that musical instruments and singing (as we know it today) are among the prohibited matters.

This PDF contains evidence of consensus for the prohibition of either some or all musical instruments, some being on singing, from twenty three scholars. These scholars encompassed all the Muslim lands, the madhhaib, and eras, so to present this matter as if it is just a difference of opinion is incredibly weak and baseless. From these twenty three scholars, three of them were Hanafis, namely Al-Bazzazi, Mahmood al-Alusi (Mufti of the Hanafis in Baghdad during his time), and Ahmad ibn 'Abd ar-Raheem at-Tahtawi. One could even argue that the scholars such as Ibn Nujaym who mentioned al-Bazzazi's consensus may also be included in this list. I refuted the claim that the issue of music is a difference of opinion in my PDF, so one may refer to that.

You can see them do it again when they say:

Musical Instruments

Due to the various textual evidence with regard to musical instruments, the scholars differed. Some scholars took a relaxed approach with regard to spiritual music, such as Imam ‘Abd al-Ghani al-Nabulsi in his Idah al-Dilalat fi Sima‘i al-Alat. Others, on the other hand, have taken a very strict approach, which is congruous to the mainstream opinion of all four schools.

There is no such thing as "strict" and "lenient" approach when it comes to Fiqh, there is only evidence to consider. This is the kind of misleading words they use which gives false implications to the reader. Clear your mind and think for a moment, what will a reader think when he sees "strict approach" and "lenient approach"? He's obviously going to think that the "strict approach" is some kind of 'extra' in the religion, and he will be vary of it. Such words do not apply to the madhhaib, for there is no "strict" and "lenient" approaches in Fiqh, only what the evidence points to.

As for An-Nablusi's Idaah ad-Dalalaat, I have read it, and the points discussed by 'Abd al-Ghani in it are of two kinds. The first is 'Abd al-Ghani refuting an absolute prohibition of "songs" (السماع والغناء​), the second being his presenting evidences for permissibility so long as the content was good, and it contained the remembrance of Allaah.

The answer to the first is that we do not claim an absolute prohibition on anything called "غناء​". Rather, we prohibited the singing that even an-Nablusi was against, and we termed singing in general as disliked due to the general texts from it, as mentioned by our scholars. The second is that An-Nablusi's evidences were either for things we did not prohibit in the first place, or the evidences themselves were weak, broken in chain, or outright fabricated. Some of his arguments were also weak, such as his argument against the famous hadeeth narrated by Al-Bukhaari from the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him):

From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful...

An-Nablusi argued that the usage of musical instruments is only prohibited when it is accompanied by the other actions mentioned in the narration. Likewise, he argued the same for statements of prohibition that came in our Fiqh books. This is a deficient argument as mentioning these actions in conjunction does not only mean it is prohibited only if it is accompanied by the others. Otherwise, could one argue from Allaah's saying:

إِنَّهُۥ كَانَ لَا يُؤْمِنُ بِٱللَّهِ ٱلْعَظِيمِ وَلَا يَحُضُّ عَلَىٰ طَعَامِ ٱلْمِسْكِينِ
Verily, he used not to believe in Allâh, the Most Great, And urged not on the feeding of Al-Miskîn (the poor). [Al-Haaqqah 69:33-34]

That disbelief in Allaah is not prohibited unless it is accompanied by not feeding the poor. Certainly this argument is not correct. The scholars of hadeeth who explained the hadeeth, and jurists who used it as evidence, none of them have explained the prohibition in this way. Perhaps this was due to 'Abd al-Ghani an-Nablusi being a prominent Sufi of his time, where gatherings of singing and musical instruments was common among the Sufis. Therefore it is likely the work was influenced by him being a Sufi, belonging to the Naqshbandi and Qaadiri groups.

Moving on, Yoosuf said:

The majority of scholars have deemed other musical instruments impermissible; the exception to this is the minority opinion allowing their use in spiritual music only.

Once again, he presented the issue as if it is a valid and legitimate scholarly difference when that is not the case. I refuted this argument in detail in the PDF. Refer to "Section 3: Claims of Ikhtilaaf".

→ Explaining and delving in spiritual music

Source: 19. Spiritual Music – Renewing Religion

This podcast was conducted by Faraz Rabbani, the so-called "Hanafi". The description says:

In this lesson, Shaykh Faraz, gives an overview of the chapter on spiritual music from Imam Ghazali’s Ihya. In this chapter, the Imam’s reference to music is constrained only to spiritual music and should be understood as such for the remainder of the lesson. This is music that inspires to seek Allah and His messenger. Within the Islamic tradition there is a broad permissibility of singing.

We see yet again Faraz Rabbani's failure to define, clarify, and present an accurate ruling. Compare that to the PDF where I clearly defined what was meant by "music", "singing" and "musical instruments". That is because before a ruling can be given, it is important to first define terms and what is understood from said terms. Faraz Rabbani saying "spiritual music", but then saying, "there is a broad permissibility of singing", this conflates "music" and "singing", as if they are synonyms. After they conflate both terms, they say:

There are numerous examples of the companions singing spiritual poems as they dug trenches or during weddings. That is also the reason why the Prophet had his own poets. Thus there was a general understanding of the permissibility of spiritual singing. The Prophet also encourage beating the ‘duff’ at weddings

This makes the entire paragraph misleading and a fabrication because the poems that the Sahaabah recited or such are not "spiritual music", as these poems had no musical instruments accompanying them, nor was the content of these poems problematic. Even if one translates the word "غناء​" as "singing", it does not allow you to say it was "spiritual music" as they attempted to do here.

Finally, they go on to say:

Conversely, however, many scholars believe that other musical instruments are not allowed within Islam. There are a minority of scholars that allowed music as long as the environment in which the music is, is not associated with other sinful acts such as dancing.

Why does Faraz Rabbani even call himself a Hanafi? It is clear he does not actually care what the Hanafi madhhab or its imams say. He uses the madhhab where it fits his agenda, but discards it away when the madhhab does not cater to his every desire.

Here, his desire was to spread music among people, using imam al-Ghazaali and his al-Ihya, however since the Hanafi madhhab would be opposing this, he forgets he was Hanafi, and repeats the same argument that Yoosuf Weltch did, playing it up to difference of opinion.

→ Literature with disbelief and polytheism is permissible

Source: Does the Shari`ah Permit Reading Non-Islamic Literature?

The questioner asks:

I was interested in understanding how non-Islamic literature (fiction novels) is viewed according to the Shariah. I understand certain things are undoubtedly impermissible, such as pornographic literature, but what about novels such as 1984, Harry Potter, Kite Runner, etc. ?

Faraz Rabbani answers:

The general ruling of literature is that it is in itself permitted, and praiseworthy insofar as it improves one’s language, communication, thinking skills, and ability to concentrate (as opposed to things like digital media). Children should be encouraged to read. Parents should, however, nudge them towards wholesome literature–and keep a good mix of Islamic literature for balance and grounding.

So far, this is good. Then he says:

As for fantasy literature, there is fantasy literature that is deeply moral and wholesome (e.g. Lord of the Rings or Chronicles of Narnia), and others of rather twisted themes.

Reading books in and of themselves is permitted, however the ruling on whether a book is prohibited or permissible depends on its contents. If a book's content is focused on prohibited matters such as magic, witchcraft, disbelief, polytheism or things such as obscenity, and immorality, then they are not permissible to read. So Faraz Rabbani calling something like "Lord of the Rings" as "wholesome" and "deeply moral" is troubling. If you simply took the words at their face value, then one may argue that it is wholesome or moral, however this is a question of Islam, you cannot judge something to be moral if its contents has things opposed in Islam. I do not have deep knowledge of "Lord of the Rings" however luckily, I know someone who does, so I asked him about it. He replied:

I started reading Tolkien's works around 8 or 9 years ago. My knowledge in Islam back then was almost non-existent and I found myself escaping to this vast fantasy world that Tolkien had written about. Initially, it became obsessive to a point where I started collecting these books so much so that I started reading the academical works such as The Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales and so on.

It didn't occur to me how deep of a rabbit hole this fake and made up mythopoeia was. When I started learning more about my deen, I started reflecting on these books and I started to understand them for what they were; fake myth devoid of reality, filled with kufr and shirk of their utmost level.

After my studies on Tawheed, kufr and shirk, I started primarily understanding the vast shirk The Silmarillion contained. All the way from a made up deity named Illuvatar and his creation, to magic and fairy tales...

One may argue that it is fantasy, and not supposed to be taken seriously, however they would only be arguing that matters of this religion should not be taken seriously, and that anything which contradicts its rules should be read so as long as "it is not taken seriously". Books and literature shares similarity when it comes to poetry. Poetry in and of itself is permitted. If the poetry is good, it is good. But if it is bad, contains obscene matters, blasphemous implications, unislamic content, then it is bad, even if the poet's intention was not to do that.

As for The Chronicles of Narnia, the two things I am aware of are that it contains magical, fantastical, and whimsical elements, and that, unlike Tolkien, who strongly disliked allegory, C.S. Lewis did make deliberate use of allegory in his writings. The Chronicles of Narnia in particular presents various Christian beliefs and ideas through its characters and story. The character Aslan, for example, is widely understood as an allegorical representation of Jesus Christ, with aspects of his character and story corresponding to Christian beliefs concerning Christ's sacrifice, death, and resurrection.

So, for Faraz Rabbani to declare these works containing some of the prohibited matters to be 'moral' only begs the question of whether he reached that conclusion based on Islam, or whether he was simply applying his own personal definition of what is considered 'moral.'

→ Tightness for clothes is difficult to define

Source: Tightness of Clothes

There is no question mentioned here, however the issue is related to tight clothes. Faraz Rabbani says about the tightness in clothes:

Tightness is, indeed difficult to specifically define. The tighter clothing is, the more disliked it would be–and when it is reasonably likely to attract undue looks as a result of the tightness, then it would become sinful as well.

How in the world is "tightness" difficult to define?! Our scholars have been very clear on tightness in clothing.

Ibn 'Aabideen said in [رد المحتار], discussing the conditions of Salaah:

His statement (does not describe what is beneath it) means that the color of the skin cannot be seen through it, as a precaution against thin clothing and the like, such as glass. His statement (and it does not matter if it clings to it) meaning, for example, that it clings to the buttocks. His statement, (and takes its shape) is grammatically connected to the preceding phrase, meaning that taking its shape is a consequence of its clinging. The wording of Sharh al-Munyah is: "However, if it is thick such that the color of the skin cannot be seen through it, but it clings to the limb and takes its shape, so that the shape of the limb becomes visible, then it should not prevent the validity of the prayer, because the required covering has been achieved."

Umm Salamah (may Allaah be pleased with her) narrated that one night the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him) woke up, saying, "None has the right to be worshipped but Allaah! How many afflictions have been sent down tonight, and how many treasures have been sent down (disclosed)! Who will go and wake up (for prayers) the lady dwellers of these rooms? How many are clothed in this world yet will be naked on the Day of Resurrection." Narrated by al-Bukhaari (5844)

Al-Haafidh Badr ad-Deen al-'Ayni said in his explanation [عمدة القاري شرح صحيح البخاري]:

He (peace and blessings upon him) warned his family and all believing women against wearing thin clothing that describes the shape of their bodies, saying: "How many are clothed in this world yet will be naked on the Day of Resurrection."It is understood from this that the punishment for a woman who wears such clothing is that she will be stripped naked on the Day of Resurrection.

One of the contemporary Hanafi scholars, Shaykh Mufti Muhammad Taqi al-'Uthmani stated in [تكملة فتح الملهم بشرح صحيح مسلم]:

Thus, every type of clothing through which a part of the private area of a man or woman becomes exposed is not approved by Islamic law ... Likewise, thin clothing, or clothing that clings to the body and reveals to the viewer the shape of a part of the body that must be covered, has the same ruling as what was mentioned above: it is prohibited and impermissible.

So why on earth is Faraz Rabbani claiming it is "difficult" to define? More so, he says:

when it is reasonably likely to attract undue looks as a result of the tightness, then it would become sinful as well.

This implies that if the clothing is tight, but does not attract undue looks, then it is permissible. This is a clear misrepresentation of the ruling. The ruling is not based on whether it attracts undue looks or not, but rather on whether it reveals the shape of the body If it does, then it is impermissible, regardless of whether it attracts undue looks or not.

Once again, I am lefting questioning why they answer questions this way. What is so hard in answering with clear, explicit terms and clarifying defining parts of the answer?

→ Ambiguous answer regarding gender interaction

Source: What Are the Limits of Gender Interaction in Business Life?

The questioner asks:

How should business life look in terms of gender interaction? Does it mean that one keeps a serious face (and not smiling)? Is it improper if one’s disposition is to use (modest subtle) humor even in business-like interactions? Where is the balance in this?

Faraz replies in pure Faraz fashion:

It is helpful in interaction with the opposite sex to distinguish between social courtesy and unnecessary socializing. The former, when there is need and benefit, is fine; it is the latter that is avoided.

Such an important topic requiring strict guidelines, yet Faraz is done with the answer in two sentences!!

How relevant are the words of shaykh al-Barkati again when he said:

Issue: In this present age, the duty upon the mufti is to exert the utmost effort in clarifying the answer due to the prevalence of ignorance. He should not answer in vague or unrestricted terms, nor should he resort to riddles or ambiguous phrasing. Instead, he should carefully consider the question, and whenever the matter calls for a detailed answer, he should provide one, addressing each point precisely.

We will now discuss why that is so. Consider Faraz's words:

It is helpful in interaction with the opposite sex to distinguish between social courtesy and unnecessary socializing.

Social curtesy would come from the customs of the people [العرف], whereas "unnecessary socializing" may be taken as meaning beyond what is the social courtesy. Based on this, when Faraz says:

The former, when there is need and benefit, is fine; it is the latter that is avoided.

Then this 'ambiguous' and 'vagueness' in definition becomes apparent, because what if the social courtesy in a country is to shake hands, while not doing so is considered "disrespectful" and "impolite"? According to the answer of Faraz, it would be perfectly fine to shake hands, that is because there is a benefit in being polite and there is a need to do so, because not doing it may lead to others ostracizing you.

Social courtesy may demand that when you speak to each other, you look each other in the eye, and talk while smiling. All of this would be permissible as well according to Faraz Rabbani.

The reason I titled the heading as "amibigous answer" is because Faraz Rabbani does not clarify nor elaborate upon the limits set by the Sharee'ah. His general words are vague, ambiguous, that can be used to justify impermissible interactions between the genders, because all you have to do is say is that it is a social courtesy, and that not doing so is disrespectful - which the sharee'ah prohibits - so there is a need for it.

One may argue against that by saying, "But Abu Zur'ah, in this article, Faraz Rabbani explains how you shouldn't shake their hand." That is true, however it misses the point of criticism. The point of criticism is not that he permits shaking hands, the point of criticism is the way he answered this question, i.e. with vague, ambiguous words that may be taken to justify impermissible actions. If a person does take his words and justify impermissible actions, that sin is on him, however it was incumbent upon Rabbani who claims to have studied under "leading Hanafi fuqaha'" to consider [آداب المفتي]. Being vague, ambiguous, and leaving the reader confused or leaving unexplained points behind is not proper for Ahlul-'Ilm (People of knowledge). The responsibility of Ahlul-'Ilm is to clarify a matter and make it clear, not complicate it and make it more confusing. Consider the famous website IslamQA.info, and how they answer a similar question. They are asked:

What is the etiquette of talking to women in general and in the following situations: buying and selling; teaching and learning; meetings to discuss work, such as explaining something specific to her? What is the ruling on lowering the gaze in these situations? When is it permissible to look at women in general? I hope that you can explain in full detail.

They replied with an answer that is detailed, in clear words, and provide proper guidelines. (Source)

→ Innovations in celebrating birthdays

Source: What Are Alternatives to Prohibited Birthday Celebrations?
Source: Best Etiquette to Follow on Birthday

Before I dive into the answers, there is some history here as well. The first link is an answer dated in November of 2024, and its last snapshot was in October 2025. After that, the page was deleted from SeekersMisguidance. The second link is apparently from 2017, and it remains as is. There is a third article dated to December 1st of 2024, which contradicted the first one. So at a time, we had a similar situation to IslamQA.org, where SeekersMisguidance hosted two contradictory answers. Then one of them was deleted. Whether it was deleted due to this contradiction or not, we do not know.

The first source, the questioner asks:

How can we explain to children that celebrations like birthdays are not part of our religion, and how can we offer alternatives to these activities?

The answerer, al-Yaqti says:

To offer alternatives for our children instead of these prohibited celebrations, we can celebrate their birthdays while avoiding imitation and steering clear of the prohibited practices associated with such events. Some of the ways to do this include.

Changing the Day of Celebration

Either by celebrating before or after the actual birthday or even extending it to several days. This is based on the principle of differentiation emphasized by our religion.

Linking the Birthday to an Accomplishment

This shifts the focus away from simply celebrating the birth. Instead, we celebrate the birthday in conjunction with achieving a significant goal or accomplishment

Al-Yaqti does not even seem to realize what the questioner asked. He asked a way to explain to children that celebrations like birthdays are not part of our religion, he did not ask whether you can celebrate birthdays or not. Al-Yaqti seems to misunderstand this. He seems to think if you celebrate birthdays in the way the non-Muslims do, this is prohibited, but it won't be if you change how you celebrate it. But the questioner is making no such distinction, nor does his question seem related to that. Al-Yaqti himself innovates up some new celebration where he tries to argue that you can just change the day you celebrate, or you connect it to an achievement or goal you meet.

The questioner asked for activities other than birthdays, while al-Yaqti starts to give "alternative" ways to celebrate birthdays. He also misunderstands why the scholars prohibited birthdays. The scholars did so on the basis it is an innovation and has no relation to the Sharee'ah, and that it is a custom of the disbelievers. Simply changing the day you celebrate birthday does not drop the underlying reason of prohibition. Likewise, connecting the birthday to an accomplishment does not drop the reason either, instead you just end up creating a new innovation, built upon the same premise as birthdays.

At the end, al-Yaqti says:

By following this approach, we can strike a balance between those who completely prohibit birthday celebrations and those who allow them with leniency in observing certain guidelines. At the same time, we can offer our children alternatives to prohibited celebrations

The Ummah being balanced and moderate does not mean you treat innovations by trying to incorporate them into the religion, then calling it "balanced" because it was prohibited. It was prohibited for a reason. Al-Yaqti should have followed the example of the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him). Anas ibn Maalik (may Allaah be pleased with him) said, the people of the Jaahiliyyah had two days each year when they would play. When the Messenger of Allaah (ﷺ) came to Al-Madeenah he said: "You had two days when you would play, but Allaah has given Muslims something instead that is better than them: the day of Al-Fitr and the day of Al-Adha." Narrated by An-Nasaa'i (1556) and Abu Dawood (1134).

Mullah 'Ali al-Qaari said in [مرقاة المفاتيح شرح مشكاة المصابيح], explaining the hadeeth:

It is understood that people were prohibited from playing and expressing joy on those two days, meaning Nawruz and Mihrijan. There is great subtlety in this, as well as an instruction to worship Allaah, because true happiness is found in worship. Allaah Most High said:
Say: In the bounty of Allaah and in His mercy — in that let them rejoice. [Yoonus 10:58]
Al-Mudhir said, "This provides evidence that honoring Nawruz, Mihrijan, and other such occasions, meaning the festivals of the disbelievers, is prohibited".

Abu Hafs al-Kabeer al-Hanafi said, "Whoever, on Nawruz, gives an egg as a gift to a polytheist in order to honor that day has disbelieved in Allaah Most High, and his deeds have been nullified."

Al-Qaadhi Abu al-Mahasin, al-Hasan ibn Mansoor al-Hanafi [Qaadhi Khan] said, "Whoever purchases something on that day that he would not normally purchase on other days, or gives someone a gift on that day: if he intends by this to honor the day in the manner in which the disbelievers honor it, then he has disbelieved. But if he intends by purchasing it to enjoy himself and indulge in leisure, and by giving the gift to express affection, merely following the customary practice, then it is not disbelief. However, it is disliked, with the dislike of resembling the disbelievers. Therefore, one should avoid it."

And Allaah knows best.

→ Unrealistic advise to father dealing with son having a girlfriend

Source: How Can I Stop My Son from Having a Girlfriend?

Before I talk on this, I clarify that the advice given here in regards to Du'a' etc is all good and encouraged, I am not calling this unrealistic.

The questioner says:

Can you please advise how to deal with a teen who is in a relationship with a girl in his school? We raised him in a practicing household. We already caught and advised him twice with consequences (by taking his phone for a certain time, setting up parental controls, etc.). The mother has now found that he is still in a relationship even though he promised it was over. Can you please advise the parents on how they should deal with this recurring problem? The boy knows it’s haram, but he keeps lying again and again. What is the best way to deal with their teenage son?

The answerer, Shazia replies:

Thank you for your question. I empathize with your frustration, and I’m sorry that he has chosen this path. I do firmly believe that he can come out of this with du`a, guidance, and love.

It is very tough to tell a young adult what to do when he doesn’t want to follow your rules. I advise you to speak to other families who are in similar situations, I advise you to make du`a for him by praying the Prayer of Need, especially before dawn, and speak to him with love, and wisdom. Make him understand the detriment of having such a relationship. Don’t resort to threats, they are not working.

So did Shazia completely ignore that the questioner has already advised the teen? The questioner says actions such as his phone being taken away and parental controls were also implemented, but Shazia seems to call these as "threats". What? Does she even know what a threat means? The questioner has already explained how the teen is lying and persisting. Why would removing the restrictions suddenly make him more receptive to the advice? The restrictions should be kept, or even made more severe if the teen is not accepting advice and refusing to give up on it.

Anas ibn Maalik (may Allaah be pleased with him) reported, a man said, "O Messenger of Allaah, should I tie my camel and trust in Allaah, or should I leave her untied and trust in Allaah?" The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, "Tie her and trust in Allaah." Narrated by At-Tirmidhi (2517).

This hadeeth explains that taking the necessary means does not contradict reliance upon Allaah, because reliance concerns the heart, whereas taking practical means involves actions of the body; therefore, there is no contradiction.

(Source)

Advising the individual to abandon the means will not accomplish anything. Even if the teen does not let it deter him, even if "love, du'a', guidance" does not help, the necessary means must still be taken.

→ Supporting a musician financially

Source: Can I Help a Musician Financially?

This question was also nuked off the platform. The answer was dated October 30th, 2024, but is no longer available. The Wayback machine was able to take some snapshots of it (19th December, 2024). So the answer was nuked within two months.

The questioner asked:

Is it permissible to donate to a musician if my intention is to help him and not support the music? Also, can I listen to the Quran on earphones to avoid hearing music, or is that disrespectful?

The answerer, Sufyaan replied:

It is always praiseworthy to give charity to a needy person. The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace be upon him) has said: “Protect yourself from hellfire even by giving a piece of date as charity.” [Bukhari]

I think Sufyaan did not realize the questioner did not say the musician is needy, nor is it indicated anywhere. More so, it is well known that the donations that musicians take is donation to support their work (as well as themselves). Even if one intends by their donation it is charity, it is still supporting another in sin and transgression. Allaah, may He be exalted, said:

وَتَعَاوَنُوا۟ عَلَى ٱلْبِرِّ وَٱلتَّقْوَىٰ ۖ وَلَا تَعَاوَنُوا۟ عَلَى ٱلْإِثْمِ وَٱلْعُدْوَٰنِ ۚ
And cooperate in righteousness and piety, but do not cooperate in sin and aggression.. [Al-Maidah 5:2]

Abu Bakr al-Jassas in [أحكام القرآن] said:

And His saying, the Most High (And cooperate with one another upon righteousness and piety) indicates, according to its apparent meaning, the obligation to cooperate in everything that constitutes obedience to Allaah Most High, because birr (righteousness) refers to acts of obedience to Allaah. And His saying, the Most High (And do not cooperate with one another upon sin and transgression) is a prohibition against assisting others in acts of disobedience to Allaah Most High.

Therefore, the answer should have been no, you should not donate to musicians.

• Controversies

I included this section due to various issues I came across while I was researching on SeekersGuidance and Faraz Rabbani. Some of the things I read were incredibly concerning hence why I saw it as necessary to include this information here. I will give my view on each issue as we go, In sha Allaah.

→ Poor Financial Situation and Management

These are the major articles that I have based this section on. All credit goes to them. They are:

  1. Report by the Board of Directors Regarding Significant Issues Involving SeekersHub Toronto and Sh. Faraz Rabbani - SeekersHub (October 2018)
  2. Traditionalist Sufi Culture Needs Accountability (2022) - Adil Khan
  3. Dear Faraz Rabbani: Where does all the Seekers' Money Go? (March 4, 2025) - Adil Khan
  4. Broken Promises and Poor Management at Seekers Guidance (March 24, 2025) - Ahmed Shaikh
  5. A Cycle That Needs to End (March 24, 2025) - Adil Khan

I have linked them here chronologically so that it helps to give us a timeline of the issues SeekersMisguidance had in its charity's finances, decpetion in getting charity, and poor management such that it is given the worst possible score.

SeekersMisguidance's poor management of its charity fund was first brought to light by one of Faraz Rabbani's former organizations called SeekersHub Toronto. They published a report on Octobor 2018 in which they mentioned various financial related claims agaisnt Faraz Rabbani, as well as others. Our focus for now is only what was related to finances and management.. Whereas on 19th July, 2019, they released a statement on Facebook saying they would no longer accept donations for the "Islamic Scholars Fund" (ISF). They said:

People have asked whether SeekersHub Toronto accepts zakat donations.

In the past, SeekersHub Toronto did accept zakat in what was referred to as the "Islamic Scholars Fund".

After review and consultation, taking into consideration regulatory and fiqh requirements and donor expectations, SeekersHub Toronto has decided to no longer collect zakat and to discontinue the Islamic Scholars Fund.

Any questions may be addressed to contact@hubtoronto.ca.

As for the report, the board (consisting of three individuals) started by mentioning the initial observations after it was established in March of 2017. They said:

The board also learned that there were a small group of students that were paid to study “full time” (through zakat funds), while also being given various work responsibilities.

During 2017, the board realized that certain operational and financial matters regarding SeekersHub Toronto were not being met. There was a lack of accountability and transparency. Also, the payment of zakat in exchange for services and being both a boss and teacher for the students was seen as questionable. In discussion with the board, Sh Faraz expressed that he had little interest in financial and administrative matters and was more interested in teaching.

In the timeframe of January-March 2018, they started investigating this issue, along with others. They mention in the report that they talked to past and current students of SeekersHub, past and current staff of both SeekersHub and SeekersGuidance, they talked to 'scholars' who taught at SeekersHub, and also from individuals outside the organization. Under the heading of what they heard regarding the organization, they write:

  • The organization lacks a clear vision, goals and strategic plan to get to measurable outcomes

  • Shaykh Faraz makes all of the decisions without true consultation from staff, students and the community. Meetings seeking input on the future of the organization occur, but do not result in any concrete action steps or strategic plan

  • Lack of transparency about how funds are used. Funds being used for other purposes than originally fundraised for, including wasteful expenditures

  • Giving, in some cases tens of thousands of dollars, to individuals or organizations without any oversight or documentation and that does not meet the direct objectives of Seekers Guidance and does not provide value to the organization. Then pressuring staff to fundraise to make up these expenditures

  • Teachers and students not being paid due to lack of funds - because of the high expenditures in other areas that Sh. Faraz would be authorizing

  • Scholars not aware that they are being paid from zakat funds (and not wanting to be paid from these funds) and in some cases sending back funds they had received.

  • No approval processes for zakat. There is no transparency on how these funds are spent. (Shaykh Faraz is the sole decision maker on the “Islamic Scholars Fund” that is comprised of zakat donations.)

The next heading to follow was events that occurred related to management and organization, as well as financial related events.

    January-May 2018

  • The board expressed concerns at board meetings (the latest being January 2018) and had asked for actions to protect the organization from operational, financial and reputational risk that could jeopardize the organization’s charitable status. Sh. Faraz agreed to these actions but did not act on them even after the board followed-up. For example, fundraising campaigns required prior consultation with the board, because, amongst other reasons, the board did not want monetary appeals to be for things outside the charitable objects of SeekersHub Toronto. The board also asked for a clear process for zakat transparency, such as an advisory board, an idea which was endorsed by Sh Faraz at the meeting but never acted upon

  • The board took an action in March that was agreed to by Sh. Faraz in 2017 (putting the names of two of the directors as bank signing authorities). Despite being copied at every stage, when the action was actually taken by the board (after failure by management to act after repeated follow-up), Sh Faraz claimed he was not consulted and that there was no agreement and that he would not cooperate

  • The board articulated that there was financial, legal and reputational risks to the organization that needed to be resolved. The board provided all of its contact information and invited any shuyukh that wanted to, to follow-up with them. No shuyukh contacted the board.

  • On April 29th, Ziyaad Vahed and Sameer Akhtar met with Sh. Faraz and the Hub management team. The agenda included matters pertaining to operational, financial and legal matters. It also included an agenda item regarding community concerns that would only include Sh. Faraz and the board. The meeting began to unfold as any board meeting but it was clear Sh. Faraz was agitated. Board members asked questions during the course of the meeting. For example, the practice of exchanging of services for payment from zakat funds was inquired about by the board and the practice was justified by Sh Faraz on the basis that it is a non-profit.

  • June-October 2018

  • During this time certain guidelines as per the board’s policies continued to be ignored. For example, the board was presented with a contract for Sh. Mohammed Abubakr Abdullah Badhib by Shireen and asked to approve it by that night since the shaykh needed it to obtain residence. This was contrary to policy which stated that before any contract would be drafted, the cost of the position would be presented to the board for approval along with the budget indicating that the cost would be covered. After asking questions (including confirmation that there was adequate funding that the Sh Badhib was okay with being paid with zakat funds) and providing some general advice on the contract, the board approved the position and the amount of the contract

  • Quarterly meetings were not planned until requested by the board, response to questions about audits were not responded to and the budget for the SeekersHub Toronto Retreat was not presented to the board as per policy.

  • On October 1, 2018, the auditor provided its report on the long-overdue 2016 audit. The report identifies significant weakness relating to the finances and records. Management later indicated to the board that they were aware of these weaknesses for over a year. See Appendix E

  • The board also requested and received information from the Treasurer (Noorin Moledina) which indicated that “funds were borrowed from the zakat account” for non-zakat eligible purposes when there was a shortfall in the operating fund.

So what did Faraz Rabbani respond to this with? Did he present a counter-report, refuting points, providing evidences, clarifying misunderstandings (if any)? No, of course not. He did none of that. Instead on January 2, 2019, he made a post on Facebook, informing people about his resignation from SeekersHub.

Thus, this is the entire lead up and context to the 2019 statement of SeekersHub. On May 28, 2020, a teacher on SeekersMisguidance (The then Dean of Academics), named Hamza Karamali made a post on Facebook saying:

Several friends, students, and observers sent me questions after my recent article on giving zakat to charitable organizations (https://www.basiraeducation.org/.../can-i-give-my-zakat...). One of these questions was an inquiry regarding my involvement in the financial oversight of the Islamic Scholars Fund at SeekersGuidance, drawing my attention for the first time to the fact that I am listed as a member of the “Islamic Scholars Fund Committee” at SeekersGuidance (see screenshot below).

I am surprised to see my name listed as a member of this committee because I have not worked for SeekersGuidance since early this year. Even while I worked for them, I had no role whatsoever in any financial oversight. I have never been privy to any of their financial records, and I was never asked to "approve" any disbursement of zakat or charity. And not only was I never a member of the “Islamic Scholars Fund Committee”, I wasn’t even aware that such a committee existed! I have sent a letter to the board of SeekersGuidance asking my name to be removed immediately.

Please note that I have no official position regarding any particular religious organization, so I am not in a position to answer questions as to whether I approve or disapprove of the way any particular religious organization disburses its zakat funds. My article on giving zakat to charitable organizations describes my position and I request anyone who would like to follow my advice to use the principles described in the article (https://www.basiraeducation.org/.../can-i-give-my-zakat...) to make their own evaluations of particular organizations.

The Annual ISF Report 2019 by SeekersMisguidance had listed Hamza Karamali as one who "assesses all applications in accordance with approved ISF policies." Subhan Allaah, not only was Hamza Karamali not on this committee, he never knew it existed!

SeekersMisguidance some days later issued, "Correction of Error Regarding Shaykh Hamza Karamali" wherein they apologized to Hamza Karamali for including his name, however so unfortunate they did not apologize to the thousands of people they deceived.

As Adil Khan said,

Millions of dollars, and the oversight committee [See next paragraph] was a total lie. Faraz Rabbani never explained who oversaw the money and no one knows what happened to it. His own org said a year prior the scholarship fund wasn’t reliable. No explanation!

So what followed after that? Then in the words of Ahmed Shaikh:

Sh. Faraz Rabbani dealt with the Seekers Hub report and Karamali fake oversight scandal by extolling growth of the fund and “clarifying” that it has a 100% distribution policy, without telling anyone what that meant or how this was accomplished. But Sh. Faraz Rabbani made three important promises. Below is a summary, and what became of them:

  1. There would be an Islamic Scholars Fund Committee. At the time it included Sh. Faraz Rabbani, Dr. Asif Padela, and a Canadian CPA, Faizan Rehman. Faizan Rehman would be removed from the reporting the very next year (2021). Dr. Asif Padela’s name, as well as Sh. Faraz Rabbani’s own name would eventually be removed as well.

  2. Seekers Guidance would provide draft and finalized mid-year financial reports and annual audited reports. They provided a “draft” once. There never were any annual audited reports. However, there were general numbers provided in annual reports up to mid-2023.

  3. Establish a “Sharia Supervisory Board.” As best as I [i.e. Ahmed] can tell, this never happened.

He continued, saying:

In the period after 2021, Sh. Faraz Rabbani included a veneer of “accountability” by claiming there were multiple people involved in the disbursement and oversight process, even as the names may have changed around. It is not clear if there was ever any deliberation.

He attached an image that showed "deliberation" was being done by: Faraz himself, Asif Padela, Yama Niazi, and Waseem Mahmood. Ahmed then mentioned that Faraz Rabbani does not bother with the names at all now. All the names he presented in prior reports were removed. We don't know who or how many people are allegedly “deliberating.”

Once this entire timeline gives you a clear picture, I move onto the more technical aspects of Faraz Rabbani's "charity". Ahmed Shaikh who we quoted is the one I am copying from now. On his substack account, his bio says:

Ahmed is a Tax, Trusts and Estates Attorney and co-author of Estate Planning for the Muslim Client (ABA Publishing, 2019). He writes about Islamic Estate Planning at islamicinheritance.com and Muslim nonprofits and leadership here.

The "Islamic Scholars Fund" (ISF) of SeekersMisguidance, its stated purpose is “to provide financial support to brilliant students of knowledge, both male and female-located worldwide-who would otherwise been forced to abandon their studies due to financial constraints.” Ahmad Shaikh assessed the most recent complete reporting for which Seekers Guidance had provided both annual reports as well as federal 990s. For those who do not know, Form 990, or officially, the "Return of Organization Exempt From Income Tax" is an IRS form that provides the public with information about a nonprofit organization.

In the ISF Annual Report (2022), SeekersGuidance claimed to have disbursed $2.1 million for the fund. The analysis presented by Ahmed started from the year 2020 since that is the year where there was the scandal associated with oversight of the Islamic Scholars Fund, followed by promises of further accountability and oversight. In the 990 forms for all years being discussed, there are two areas of disbursements that deal with the Islamic Scholarship Fund: “ISF Students” and “Onetime ISF Payments.” There is a third category that may not be related to ISF, but it was accounted separately in case it is, called “Teachers and Scholars.” Ahmed presented the following image:

Islamic Scholars Fund disbursement discrepancy

The image shows what SeekersGuidance claims to have disbursed in its marketing materials and what was the actual amount they filed in its 990 forms. If we assume the best that "teachers and scholars" is part of ISF, then the discrepency is minor in 2021 (only $825), however in 2022, it exceeds over a million dollars ($1,189,116 in total). In 2023, even though SeekersGuidance never released its annual report (and did not release anything after that either), we did get a Mid-Year Report (2023). In this report, SeekersGuidance claimed to have disbursed $1.7+ million dollars. However, if you look at their Form 990 for 2023, page 10, then total ISF (assuming "teachers and scholars" is also part of it) is $654,246. If you compare this to their claimed $1.7 million, there is a discrepency of $1,045,754. Do note that this figure is not similar to the ones for the years 2020-2022, since those were based on annual reports.

Another issue related to baffling finances is how SeekersGuidance in its 990 forms note they have no employees, yet have payrolls. For instance, in the year 2023, they claimed they had 0 employees, yet it still had a payroll of $881,420. If there are alternative arrangements for payroll, like use of contractors, this should have been explained in the 990 form. It was not.

So is it a surprise that according to Charity Navigator, SeekersGuidance Inc. is rated 1/5, which is the worst rating you can get.. Charity Navigator key findings were: a lack of independent directors, no financial statements and the 990 was not posted on the website, a liability to asset ratio of 542.49%, and a working capital ratio of only 0.12 years.

A liability-to-asset ratio of 542.49% means that the organization owes far more money than the value of everything it owns. For example, imagine someone owns $10 but owes $54. Their debt is more than five times what they own. That is roughly what a 542.49% ratio is telling us. SeekersGuidance Inc. has a very large amount of debt compared to what it owns.

A working capital ratio of 0.12 tells us whether an organization has enough money or easily available assets to pay its bills in the near future. A ratio of 0.12 means that for every $1 it needs to pay soon, it has only about 12 cents available to cover it.

As you might imagine, any independent Board of Directors that actually cared about the organization’s mission and wanted to keep faith with donors would regard it as an extreme breach of fiduciary duty to allow such an executive director to hold any position of trust at all. As it happens, Faraz Rabbani has a history with an independent board. It did not go well.

There are many testimonies as well. For instance, under the post of Ahmed Shaikh, a user named Amir comments:

I wanted seekers guidance to succeed. From around 2015-2020 I would respond to most of their appeals and donated much sadaqa and zakaat, enrolled in online classes, and even volunteered as a TA in a shafii course. They were times when:

  1. they would have appeals for electronic equipment like cameras, mics and stuff and that appeal would linger on after I contributed and I would say I'm just gonna fund it all and after I would do that they would continue appealing to that cause

  2. the same thing would happen with raising money for different shaykhs on different occassions ( at first I was gullible thinking it might have been people forgetting to take it down and some sort of automatic reach occurred requesting funds of an initiative that has been met. however, onetime i asked why are you asking for a cause already met and i got a response saying it is for him and others similar

  3. They would repurpose videos, usually converted sisters, who was used to raise funds for initiatives already met sometimes even year(s) later

  4. They reached out to me privately to raise funds using individuals saying not to say anything (I'm convinced it was shenanigans).

  5. they would use people who know how to raise money and take advantage of Muslims who want to do khair

In the article titled, "Dear Faraz Rabbani: Where does the Seekers' Money go?", Adil Khan points out deceptive tactics they employ. He points out the constant shifting of fundraising targets and purposes. How they take donations under different names, with different entities, yet leading to the same donation link. It is funny to see them asking for $125,000 and after the goal is met, they change it to $500,000! The value quadruples without any transparency as to why they increased it.

In conclusion to this heading, I would like to say that the various issues raised here does not mean definitively that Faraz Rabbani is guilty of fraud or stealing funds, I am not accusing him or SeekersMisguidance of such. However, it does indicate that there are serious issues with Faraz Rabbani, his handling of SeekersMisguidance, and the abysmal finances of his organization, not to mention being rated with the lowest possible rating for charities. This is not the kind of person you should be handing your charity to, nor someone who should be trusted with funds in the first place. If the claims mentioned by SeekersHub are true, then this is a pattern that spans years, with no evidence to say he has bettered himself.

→ Ill Manners and Deplorable Behavior

The report that was released by SeekersHub did not only focus on financial issues that they had to face with Faraz Rabbani. Rather, they have also said tells us that Faraz Rabbani lacks proper manners and behavior, his conduct with those around him does not fit a normal Muslim, let alone a so-called "scholar".

Source linked once again to make it easy for reference: Report by the Board of Directors Regarding Significant Issues Involving SeekersHub Toronto and Sh. Faraz Rabbani - SeekersHub (October 2018)

From the initial observations of the board of SeekersHub, they said:

During 2017, the board realized that certain operational and financial matters regarding SeekersHub Toronto were not being met. There was a lack of accountability and transparency. Also, the payment of zakat in exchange for services and being both a boss and teacher for the students was seen as questionable. In discussion with the board, Sh Faraz expressed that he had little interest in financial and administrative matters and was more interested in teaching. The Board realized that he might not be a good fit as a manager and may be happier if some of those burdens were transferred to someone else.

Hence the next point:

In September 2017, the board suggested, for Sh. Faraz’s consideration, a revised organizational structure with someone else handling managerial responsibilities (at SeekersHub Toronto only, not Seekers Guidance) that would report to the board and Sh Faraz could focus on a full-time teaching role. (See Appendix B) This proposal was forcefully rejected by Sh. Faraz with hostility and anger. The board, out of respect to Sh. Faraz and concern for the organization, decided to not push this approach for the time being, but rather to just take a more active oversight role to ensure that at least legal obligations of the organization were being fulfilled.

We get a glimpse of the real Faraz Rabbani in the very second page of the report. This pattern is recurring as we will see. In the very next heading wherein the board discusses further issues and investigations, they write:

  • During the Fall of 2017, the board also heard from other students that a student was >banned from the Hub after being yelled at by Sh. Faraz.

  • Soon after in December 2017, a group of students asked to meet privately and confidentially with the board wherein they outlined concerns around operations and behaviour of Sh. Faraz.

  • Sh. Faraz has a history of being dismissive of concerns raised by the board and others. He has been disrespectful to the board, staff, students and community members.

This is where the board began their investigation into the matter, and invited anyone to come forward and talk to the board privately. As we mentioned before, they talked to a bunch of people, current and former students, staff, and inviduals outside the organzation. The board said:

We have evidence of Sh. Faraz’s behaviour going back to 2011 beginning with SeekersGuidance and continuing over the last seven year

However they did not share this due to people talking to them on the condition of anonymity. Regardless, it means when the board presents these claims, they also acknowledge they have proof for it. Claims include:

  • The hiring of staff that are unqualified, bullying of these staff until they leave or are fired. This happens with qualified staff as well. The bullying can happen publicly at the Hub, over whatsapp and other online forums for all staff/volunteers to see.

  • Firings of staff and students without cause or compensation

They dedicated a heading specifically for his behavior. They write under it:

  • Sudden explosive anger. In some cases a person(s) will be verbally abused for hours. In two cases students were physically grabbed and shaken. These explosions have happened publically and without regard for who is around, leading to other volunteers and the public hearing and witnessing the behaviour. The board of directors has also experienced some of this behaviour directly i.e. yelling at the board as students walk into the Hub for class. Shuyukh have also been the direct recipients of this behaviour. Students and staff indicate these moments occur more often during stressful periods.

  • Continuous verbal abuse and the use of demeaning language and use of guilt with students and volunteers (e.g. telling them how useless they are, lazy, also use of demeaning language when addressing them). This can occur even during a lesson as he is teaching

  • Manipulation - e.g. of spouses against one another. Asking multiple people to give up their jobs/work for the organization or to study because he saw a dream of the Prophet (saws) giving them a key. We have also heard that he told someone to get married to a particular person based on such a dream, and then later did the same for someone else and cited a similar dream.

  • Lying to staff

  • Backbiting of staff/students/board of directors in front of other staff/students

  • Telling lies to others about staff - these were reported to be lies about the person’s character and family relations.

  • Slandering staff/students who have left the organization and spreading this slander with others outside the organization

  • There are individuals who still suffer severe anxiety attacks as a result of their experiences.

About scholars, they said:

It's become clear that many scholars have heard about these behaviours from students of SeekersHub Toronto. Since some of the behaviour have occurred in public, it is safe to assume that many in the public know as well.

Now we arrive at the heading of January-May 2018 events, this comes from the board's own experience.

  • The board took an action in March that was agreed to by Sh. Faraz in 2017 (putting the names of two of the directors as bank signing authorities). Despite being copied at every stage, when the action was actually taken by the board (after failure by management to act after repeated follow-up), Sh Faraz claimed he was not consulted and that there was no agreement and that he would not cooperate. Sh. Faraz also said he cannot work this the board and that “it is best to find a board with better attitude and more contribution beyond being a nuisance”

  • 3 staff and 1 student left SeekersHub Toronto and Seekers Guidance from December 2017 to February 2018. The student left in February 2018 because he was verbally abused and yelled at by Sh. Faraz. Many staff and students witnessed this behaviour first hand. Later when speaking to others, Sh. Faraz tried to blame the student’s leaving on the student and not due to Sh Faraz’s own behaviour. This student had received similar treatment a few times before in the preceding year.

  • Advice from a mental health professional [!!!!]: The board sought advice from a mental health professional as to the what it was observing in Sh. Faraz’s behaviour. The professional indicated that they cannot perform a diagnosis without speaking with a client but noted that, generally speaking, where the behaviours described happen consistently over an extended period of time, it indicates that they are deeply imbedded and would require significant long-term therapy to treat them.

The board in pages (6,7) write in depth that there some back and forth going between them and Faraz Rabbani regarding their "differences". What caught my eye was this:

On April 25, unknown to the board of directors at the time, an email was sent out to shuyukh, students, staff and volunteers of SeekersHub Toronto saying that the board was working to destabilize the organization by spreading false statements about Sh. Faraz’s fitness to lead the organization both locally and internationally. The email asked that the board be told to step down and that a new board be put in place. It named individuals that volunteer or work for the Hub as the prospective new board. The email provided the email addresses of the board members.

Such a petty and vindictive man Faraz Rabbani is. No wonder the mental health specialist said (generally speaking), therapy is needed. Just four days after the above incident occurred, this happened (29th of April)

On April 29th, Ziyaad Vahed and Sameer Akhtar met with Sh. Faraz and the Hub management team. The agenda included matters pertaining to operational, financial and legal matters. It also included an agenda item regarding community concerns that would only include Sh. Faraz and the board. The meeting began to unfold as any board meeting but it was clear Sh. Faraz was agitated. Board members asked questions during the course of the meeting. For example, the practice of exchanging of services for payment from zakat funds was inquired about by the board and the practice was justified by Sh Faraz on the basis that it is a non-profit. Sh. Faraz described the questions (and past questions) as the board being “hostile.” Soon after Sh. Faraz blew up and began to yell at the board members. Staff/students quickly moved to separate the board from Sh. Faraz. The board went into another room. After some time Sh. Faraz entered the room and continued to yell at the board accusing them of betraying him. He made oaths that either the board goes or he does. The board exited the building and staff attempted to calm to Sh. Faraz down as students began to walk in for class. Staff came outside to speak to the board. Eventually Sh. Faraz came out as well and continued to yell at the board. Eventually the board members left the Hub.

This is the behavior of a child whose parents took candy from him, for his sake.

Then we enter the June-October 2018 events, where Faraz Rabbani continues with the behavior he has displayed. They wrote:

The board also became aware that Sh. Faraz was still directing all staff during this period and that there continued to be abuse of staff

And they wrote:

In September, Sh Faraz sent Zafar Rana to talk privately to Ziyaad and ask again for the board to step down. Ziyaad responded that the board does not intend to step down and remains committed to its duties towards the organization and community...As a result of these ongoing issues and the fact that the board’s requests for meetings with Sh. Faraz had not been respected, the board sent an email to Sh. Faraz asking for an urgent meeting. A meeting was scheduled for September 24. At the time of scheduling (September 23) Sh. Faraz sent out another email to shuyukh, staff, volunteers and other members in the community not affiliated with SeekersHub asking for the board to step down and for the concerns to be handed over to a new board and to Sh. Zahir for mediating.

The next heading is then about allegations made against the board. Due to their length, I am not going over them, however you are free to do so. I remind the reader that Faraz Rabbani has not rejected or talked about this report at all. Perhaps that is because he knows what SeekersHub board exposed and highlighted of his pathetic lack of manners and behavior, it is all true with too many witnesses and evidences to deny.

In conclusion to their report, the board wrote:

the board has come to the conclusion that there are in fact consistent patterns of behaviour that must be addressed. Addressing these behaviours are necessary to reduce harm to individual staff, students and scholars, preserve the integrity of both organizations, assist Sh. Faraz with his own healing and preserve his reputation, and allow for continued learning and benefit for the community. Allowing Sh. Faraz’s behaviour to continue would place all of these areas in jeopardy.

It is clear that much of Sh. Faraz’s behaviour is known throughout the community. The fact that this behaviour has not been made public (e.g. on social media) is due to the generosity of students/staff/scholars/members of the public that have been affected. Indeed the board has already seen social media posts from individuals previously affiliated with the Hub describing Sh. Faraz’s behaviour without naming him. If these posts were to name him in the future it would have detrimental consequences to all of the work of SeekersHub Toronto and SeekersGuidance.

There are many individuals who came forward and exposed Faraz Rabbani. One of them is Zeeshan Qaasimi who said in a facebook post:

I was pretty involved in Seekers Guidance management a few years back. So seeing this does not come as a shock to me.

Scholars, SG staff, and others in the Muslim community are very well aware of Faraz Rabbani's history. In addition to a lot of the points I see in this article, I'm well aware of Faraz Rabbani's years of poor treatment of others particularly students and volunteers.

Students are pressured to change their life plans - work or school- and he has convinced them that he will take them on a journey of Islamic scholarship. After they have made significant life altering plan changes in their lives, he has completely left them hanging in the lurch. Laying waste to years of their lives as they are then forced to scramble to figure out what is next in their life.

So fine, some of these students can then proceed to study elsewhere, right? But unfortunately, he has then told these same students that he knows their other teachers better than they do and that he has the power to destroy all of their reputations.

When students have spoken out, rather than reflect or take their concerns seriously, he has leveraged his connections in the scholarship circles to further silence any dissent. He often cited ideas like those that disrespect teachers will face a bad ending in their life, as a way of silencing genuine concerns and criticism. Of course we believe in respecting teachers, unfortunately we see it too often deployed now as a power play.

Why don't his colleagues expose him? Some have tried. and some shaykh friends of his are co-conspirators and are okay with manipulating and abusing students as much as he is. They are also covered for by Faraz when they abuse.

Other issues that I have heard of since my departure many years ago. A scholar who was in a secret marriage that was platformed and whose wife was pacified with promises of redress that never came. Delayed payments to teachers.

If this is true, then how ironic that in the [Polygamy Heading], they fight tooth and nail against the ruling of the Sharee'ah when it comes to others, but have no issue in using the ruling for their own desires and whims.

One may refer to other such instances here: Faraz Rabbani: A Cycle of Abuse That Must End

With all that in its place, I also found an alleged instance of Faraz Rabbani lying upon Shaykh Mufti Taqi al-'Uthmani, using his name for legitiamcy in his beliefs of al-Istighathah. See: Forum post on MuftiSays.

Unfortunately, the image is no longer available, however considering that no one called it out, and that a scholar supposedly reached out to shaykh al-'Uthmani, then it is likely this was a real incident.

→ Mystery of "Checked and Approved Faraz Rabbani"

This heading exists because it was something I always suspected, namely that "Checked and Approved by Faraz Rabbani" is added for its own sake, and that Faraz Rabbani does not actually check it, nor approve it. In my research on the controversies, I found that the aforementioned Adil Khan already had a post on his blog about this. See: “Checked and approved” by Faraz Rabbani?

Supposedly, there was a “porn answer” on SeekersGuidance from an individual called Hamdi who said that watching a little segment of porn is worse than committing 100 fornications. Faraz Rabbani - even though he said it was wrong - tried to justify it, saying:

A minor sin can become worse than a major sin if the former becomes a habit; isn't repented form (typo, likely meant from); or results in wider harms. However, in and of itself, a major sin is undeniably worse than a minor sin.

Adil Khan argued:

So it’s one instance of a “minor” sin compared to 100 acts of a major sin. So why does Faraz justify this as a potentially repeated minor sin being worse than a major sin, when the SeekersGuidance answer was of the major sin (done 100 times) being less than the minor sin.

Adil Khan also pointed out similar tactics being used by Faraz Rabbani. In a twitter post, an individual named Nihal Khan condemned Daniel Haqiqatjou for "online shaming of a Muslim sister because she put up a picture of herself." Rabbani retweeted it, saying: "Agreed".

Then I am assuming he was called out on Facebook, so he replied to a "Syed Shaheeruddin Ahmed", saying:

What did I say about DH? I shared one post. That's all.

This is more than just a share, and it was also clearly about DH. As Adil Khan put it, he is indeed "a subtle maneuver type of guy who finds his ta’weel in strange fiqh loopholes to justify his lies."

I will say that this heading is not as important or big as the other two. While I was able to independently verify the other two headings, I was not able to verify this one, nor did I feel like doing so due to how insignificant it is, compared to the other matters. However, it is still worth mentioning because it is a pattern of behavior that is consistent with our assessment of him.

Conclusion

Though the article is focused on both IslamQA.org and SeekersMisguidance, much of my criticism is related to SeekersMisGuidance and its owner Faraz Rabbani. The hypocrisy, deviancy and misguidance of this person cannot be stated enough. And if you turn a blind eye to our scientific criticisms, then his actions alone are evidence against him. How can this man go around claiming to guide others, "improving" the west when he's an example of the west's worst? Indeed, 'Abdullah ibn al-Mubarak said, "I sought manners for twenty years. And I sought knowledge for thirty years. They (i.e. righteous generations) used to seek manners before knowledge." Faraz Rabbani is a man who has neither manners nor knowledge, and yet he claims to be a scholar and a spiritual guide for others.

However, the most unfortunate part is that despite all we have discussed, there are still people who would run to his defense, and dismiss us due to ignorance and blind love for SeekersMisguidance and Faraz Rabbani. It is a very common for these people to do that, using excuses like "Salafi/wahhabi" as if that would refute all what we wrote. Their worldview is so narrow, they cannot accept that people they look up to, are not what they seemed to be, so they double, triple, no even quadruple down on their defense. So I extend an invitation to any supporter of SeekersMisguidance that if they truly wish to discuss this matter with me, and are sincere in their intention, then I am available, In sha Allaah.

ربنا تقبل منا إنك أنت السميع العليم وارحم علينا إنك انت التواب الرحيم وصلى الله تعالى على خير خلقه محمد وعلى آله وأصحابه اجمعين وعلى جميع علماء المسلمين