Definition of 'Aqeedah
It states in the book Mujmal Usool Ahl as-Sunnah by Shaykh Naasir ibn Abd al-Kareem al-'Aql:
As for creed in its technical sense, it has two meanings. The general meaning encompasses every creed, whether a true creed or a false creed held by the people of falsehood. It means firm belief and certain conviction that leaves no room for doubt in the one who holds it.
As for Islamic creed, it means certainty, submission, and firm belief in Allaah, Mighty and Majestic, and in what is due to Him in terms of tawheed, worship, and obedience. Then belief in His angels, His books, His messengers, the Last Day, divine decree, and all the other foundations of faith. Then the pillars of Islam and other matters that are definitive. These are many, such as intercession and the seeing of Allaah, as well as practical matters that are among the definitive matters of the religion, such as commanding what is right and forbidding what is wrong, jihaad, loving for the sake of Allaah, hating for the sake of Allaah, and similar matters that fall under the obligations.
It also includes matters concerning relationships among Muslims, such as loving the Companions, may Allaah be pleased with them, loving the righteous early generations, loving the scholars, loving the righteous, and similar matters that fall under the foundations and established principles of creed.
(Source)
Definition of Ahadeeth al-Mutawaatir
As for the mutawaatir report, it is that which is narrated by a large number of people such that it is ordinarily impossible for them to have agreed upon a lie. This large number must be present in every level of the chain. This type of report is entirely accepted, and there is no need to investigate its narrators.
Definition of Ahadeeth al-Ahad
Hadeeth al-Ahad refers it is that which does not fulfill the conditions of mutawatir. With regard to the number of its narrators, it is divided into three categories: mashhoor, 'azeez, and ghareeb. As for the mashhoor, it is that which is narrated by three or more narrators at every level, without reaching the level of mutawaatir. The 'azeez is that whose number of narrators does not fall below two at any level of the chain. The third category - the ghareeb - is that which is narrated exclusively by a single narrator. These three categories are what are called the Hadeeth al-Ahad.
In this article, I've translated it mostly as "singular report(s)". Do not confuse that by thinking we are discussing a single report (as in one in number), rather that we've translated it as reports which are Ahad.
Authority of Ahad in 'Aqeedah
• View of Ahlul-Kalaam
The Ash'aris hold that it is not permissible to use ahadeeth al-ahad as evidence in matters of creed,
because they are probabilistic in their indication [ظَنِّيَّةُ الدَّلالةِ] and do not convey certainty.
They only allow using them as evidence in rulings of jurisprudence.
Abu al-Ma'ali al-Juwayni said:
As for the hadeeths that they use as evidence, they are singular reports that do not lead to
knowledge. Even if we were to disregard all of them, that would be acceptable. However, we will indicate
an interpretation for what has been recorded among them in the authentic books.
Ar-Razi said:
Singular reports are based on probability, so it is not permissible to rely upon them in knowing
Allaah, Most High, and His attributes. We say that they are probabilistic because we are agreed that the
narrators are not infallible.
At-Taftazaani said:
The report of a single narrator, even assuming that it contains all the conditions mentioned in
the principles of jurisprudence, conveys nothing but probability. Probability has no consideration in
matters of belief.
(Source)
As for the Matureediyyah, they also believe it is not permissible to use singular reports as evidence in matters of creed, because they are probabilistic in their indication and do not convey certainty. They only permit using them as evidence in rulings of jurisprudence. (Source)
Al-Matureedi explicitly stated that they cannot be used as evidence in matters of creed. He mentioned that a singular report does not necessitate knowledge because it does not reach the level of a mutawatir report in necessitating knowledge and testimony. However, acting upon it is obligatory. See: [التوحيد]
• View of Ahlus-Sunnah
The correct position, which is also the position of Ahlus-Sunnah wa'l Jama'ah is that authentic singular reports (ahadeeth al-ahad) are themselves authoritative proof in matters of creed and rulings. No distinction is made between them and mutawatir hadeeths.
This was only known from the Mutakallimeen, for the Sahaabah, the Tabi'een, Atba' at-Tabi'een, and the people of Sunnah and Hadeeth continued to use these reports as evidence in matters of creed and rulings, without making any distinction between the two. It has not been transmitted from any of them that they permitted using these reports as evidence in matters of rulings while rejecting them when reporting about Allaah, His names, and His attributes.
The evidence for this, comes from the Quraan, the Sunnah and Ijmaa', namely that the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him)would send a number of his Companions to different regions to teach the people the fundamentals and branches of the religion, matters of creed and rulings. He sent 'Ali, Mu'adh, Abu Moosa, and other Companions. In fact, he said to Mu'adh, as recorded in the two Saheehs:
You are going to a people from the People of the Book, so let the first thing you call them to be that they worship Allaah alone...
In another narration:
... To worship Allaah alone. If they obey you in that, then inform them that Allaah has obligated upon them five prayers every day and night. If they obey you in that, then inform them that Allaah has obligated upon them a charity, taken from their wealthy and returned to their poor.
Narrated by Al-Bukhaari (7372) and Muslim (19).
Thus, he instructed him to give precedence to calling them to creed and Tawheed (monotheism) over the other pillars of Islam. It has not been transmitted that any of those messengers limited themselves to conveying only the practical branches and rulings. This confirms that matters of creed can be established through a singular report and that proof is established by it.
Likewise, his letters and writings (peace and blessings upon him) that he sent to kings, calling them to Islam and to worship Allaah alone, served to convey the message and establish the proof against them, even though the messengers carrying them were individuals. If a singular report were not accepted in matters of creed, it would have been necessary for him to send a group to every region who reached the level of mass transmission, so that certainty could be attained through their reports.
It is likewise established by consensus (Ijmaa') that it is obligatory to accept ahad hadeeths equally in matters of creed and rulings. Imam Ash-Shaafi'i (may Allaah have mercy on him) said in his famous [الرسالة]:
If it were permitted to say regarding specialized knowledge, "The Muslims, both in the past and present, have unanimously agreed on affirming and accepting singular reports, for there is no Muslim jurist known to me who did not affirm them," then I could say that. However, I say, I have not heard any report from the jurists of the Muslims indicating that they differed over affirming the authority of singular reports. Rather, as I have described, this is something that is established among all of them.
Imam Ibn 'Abd al-Barr (may Allaah have mercy on him) likewise also transmitted a consensus of the Muslims, explicitly stating that they accepted singular reports, even in matters of creed. He stated in [التمهيد]:
And all of them [i.e. he means the jurists and hadeeth scholar] adhere to the report of a trustworthy individual in matters of creed, and they show allegiance and enmity on its basis, and regard it as part of the Sharee'ah and religion in their beliefs. This is the position held by the group of Ahlus-Sunnah.
Imam Abu Bakr al-Khateeb al-Baghdadi (may Allaah have mecry on him) said in [الكفاية في علم الرواية]:
All of the Successors (Tabi'een), and the jurists who came after them in all the various regions of the Muslim lands up to our time, acted upon singular reports. We have not received any report from any of them rejecting this or objecting to it. Therefore, it is established that accepting and acting upon such reports is part of the religion of all of them. For if there had been among them anyone who did not hold that it was permissible to act upon them, a report of his position on the matter would have reached us.
Abu al-Mudhaffar as-Sama'ni in [الانتصار لأصحاب الحديث] stated:
When a report is authentic from the Messenger of Allaah ﷺ, and it is narrated by trustworthy narrators and leading scholars, with later generations transmitting it from their predecessors back to the Messenger of Allaah ﷺ, and the Ummah has received it with acceptance, then it necessitates knowledge in matters where knowledge is attainable through such reports. This is the position of the people of Hadeeth, generally, and the proficient scholars who uphold the Sunnah. As for the view that is mentioned, that a singular report does not convey knowledge under any circumstances, and that it must necessarily be transmitted through tawatur [mass transmission] for knowledge to be attained through it, this was something invented by the Qadariyyah and Mu'tazilah, whose aim was to reject the reports.
As for Imam Abu Haneefah and his two students (may Allaah have mercy on them), then although nothing explicit is narrated from them, their principles and general words suffice in proving what we mentioned earlier, that they did not differentiate between if the narration is singular or massly transmitted when it came to creed. Imam at-Tahaawi (may Allaah have mercy on him), when discussing the believers seeing Allaah in Paradise said:
And everything that has come in this regard in an authentic hadeeth from the Messenger of Allaah ﷺ is as he said ...
One sees that Imam at-Tahaawi mentioned the reports from the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him) when it came to seeing Allaah in the Hereafter, relying on these authentic reports for a creedal issue. Similarly, he said:
All of what is authentic from the Messenger of Allaah, peace and blessings be upon him, of the Law and clear teachings are true.
An interesting thing to note here is the place where Imam at-Tahaawi said this statement in. When one looks into it, he sees that Imam at-Tahaawi mentioned this while he was discussing about faith (الإيمان). One may wonder why that is so? That is because Imam at-Tahaawi is refuting exactly what the Ahlul-Kalaam held, and did when it comes to this matter, as indicated by Ibn Abi al-'Izz who said:
His statement (All of what is authentic from the Messenger of Allaah, peace and blessings be upon him, of the Law and clear teachings are true)
By this, the Shaykh, may Allaah have mercy on him, intends to refute the Jahmiyyah, the Mu'attilah, the Mu'tazilah, and the Raafidah, who claim that narrations are of two types, mutawaatir (mass-transmitted) and ahaad (singular). They say that the mutawaatir - even if its chain of transmission is definitive - is not definitive in its indication, because verbal proofs do not give certainty. For this reason, they cast doubt upon the Quraan's indication regarding the Attributes [of Allaah]. They said: And as for the ahaad, they do not give [certain] knowledge, and they cannot be used as proof, neither from the perspective of their chain of transmission nor from the perspective of their text. Thus, they blocked hearts from knowing the Lord, Most High, His Names, His Attributes, and His Actions through the Messenger, and they redirected people to illusory concepts and imaginary premises, which they called rational arguments and conclusive proofs.
... And it is astonishing that they gave these things precedence over the texts of revelation, and on their account they set the texts aside. Consequently, their hearts became barren of guidance through the revealed texts, while they failed to attain sound reasoning supported by sound natural disposition and the Prophetic texts. Had they allowed the texts of revelation to be the judge, they would have attained sound rational understanding that accords with the sound natural disposition.
Rather, every group among the people of innovation subjects the texts to its innovation and to what it considers rational. Whatever agrees with it, it says, 'This is clear and decisive,' and accepts it and uses it as evidence! Whatever contradicts it, it says, 'This is ambiguous,' and then rejects it, calling its rejection tafweed. Or it distorts it, calling its distortion ta'weel. For this reason, Ahlus-Sunnah strongly denounced them.
[شرح العقيدة الطحاوية]
Ibn Abi al-'Izz al-Hanafi also said in [شرح العقيدة الطحاوية]:
The report of a single narrator (khabar al-wahid), when the Ummah receives it with acceptance, acting upon it and affirming it, conveys certain knowledge according to the majority of the Ummah. It is one of the two categories of mutawatir reports. There was no disagreement about this among the early generations of the Ummah.
Therefore in brief, the position of Ahlus-Sunnah (which is the correct position) is that authentic singular reports (Ahadeeth al-Ahad) are binding and authoritative proof in matters of creed just as they are in jurisprudence. Even if singualr reports are only probalistic in their indication, then they become definitive and certain when the Ummah accepts the report, believe in it and act upon it. Therefore, rejecting singular reports in Creed is not but an innovation introduced by Ahlul-Kalaam to set aside shar'i textual evidences in favor of philosophical premises.